“Glee” is Back With Secret Anti-American Messages, Chubby Actors
The TV show “Glee” made a splashy return to the airwaves this month, with new characters and extensive choir numbers. Fans quickly took to their blogs to celebrate the implausible survival of the series, while some journalists, political pundits and religious leaders condemned the peculiar show for its poor ethical choices and subversive messages. The insults directed at Governor Sarah Palin were a particular sore point for many reporters, as was the homoerotic shirtless dance scene starring 80s pop icon Madonna.
Glee, which began as a second-tier show about singing high school students, has built a strong audience among children and teens who are drawn to its quirky personalities and adult humor. This success has lead many television experts to take a closer look at the series, resulting in Christwire’s advisory report, “What Every Parent Should Know About The TV Show Glee,” which was widely distributed across the world wide web. Most parents seemed concerned that Glee was promoting homosexuality, atheism and careers in the arts while dismissing Christianity and traditional athletics. Others found the show far too unrealistic and thus a negative influence on children who could be tempted to pursue vanity projects.
The Sarah Palin/Madonna Fiasco
One of the most egregious acts in Glee’s history occurred on the first episode of this season. In a highly controversial scene, Lesbian Sue Sylvester mocked Vice Presidential candidate Sarah Palin by calling her “stupid.” Critics were outraged, pointing out that it was highly inappropriate to introduce secret political messages in a children’s show. Others suggested that campaign finance laws make such political advertising possibly against federal law. John Nolte of the popular gossip blog, “Big Hollywood” spoke for many parents when he stated:
“The creators are all about getting between you and your kids with their political and social agendas. They know Palin is a growing political force and nothing’s off the table when it comes to marginalizing her — even at the expense of their own show’s entertainment value — even at the expense of audience share.” –John Notle, “Big Hollywood”.
The second episode poses a different problem for critics. For the most part, it lacks a plot. Composed almost entirely of singing numbers, there was little meat to this show. Its central focus (and a huge draw for the homosexual audience) was a lengthy scene involving 80s pop star Madonna. The premise here is that the cast needs to make a raunchy music video and calls on Madonna for help. Many will remember the notorious performer from her younger days when she introduced sadomasochistic sex to the music business for big bucks. Her return in this episode seems almost instructional, as if she’s teaching a new generation how to sell their young flesh to a hungry adult audience. Today, the billionaire performer Madonna has renounced her America citizenship and lives in an English castle with several boys that she adopted from Africa and an extensive crew of servants that services her every whim.
The Madonna video scene was shot in voluptuous black and white. The camera focuses on various young men, some ethnic, who dance a striptease while singing about the ladies fashion magazine “Vogue” (made famous by the movie “Devil Wears Prada”). Madonna dances alongside these children (some of whom are probably not much older than her own sons). She visibly lusts after them, reaching out to grab their bare bodies. Her giant tongue makes obscene gestures as these boys move in a pinnacle of sexual energy, throwing their thin arms in the air as if they’re as weightless as doves. The homosexual character Kurt appears, flaunting his naked body and batting his eyelashes in a sexual frenzy. He gyrates his pelvis in alluring ways as if begging the young men of America to rub up against their television screens in passion and sympathy. But all that promise comes to naught. The scene climaxes abruptly, adding absolutely nothing to the plot of the show.

“Weighty” Character Issues
Both supporters and detractors alike were surprised to see the actors on this show return with bloated, haggard looks. Football player Finn in particular looks like he has gained 30 pounds. To combat this, Glee’s wardrobe department has taken to dressing him in black to hide his obvious weight problem. Unfortunately, he is clumsy in his new chunky frame, stomping around the stage recklessly and always looking as if he might fall over. He has lost his grace and surely there will be no shower scenes this season featuring a bare-chested Finn. One has to wonder if the fame has gone to his head or if Hollywood alcohol parties are the cause of his incredible girth. Is there a chance this boy will go down the John Travolta/Val Kilmer route of gaining over a 100 pounds and from there on playing middle-aged hoodlums?
Will Schuster and Emma Pillsbury (the woman he cheats on his wife with) both reappeared looking surprisingly pale and haggard. Makeup cannot hide the deep lines on their faces nor their rough, jagged chins. In fact, it is an excess of face powder that makes both actors look uniquely ridiculous, like circus clowns decorated in a dark room. The leathery texture of their skin is reminiscent of the Marlboro man and leads one to wonder if they’ve both taken up smoking cigarettes or worse. Other actors who have gained a significant amount of weight and look bad in their makeup include the Football Coach, Sue Sylvester and Rachel, the girl of Jewish descent.
On the topic of the Jewish girl Rachel, her lack of singing ability was made painfully clear with the awkward lip-synching in the first episode of the season. The voice pumped through America’s tv speakers didn’t even sound close to hers. To cover up this fiasco, the show’s directors created an offensive plot that included lesbianism, codependency and prostitution (the character Sue sells her body to the school’s Hindu principal). How realistic is it to have a Jewish character in Ohio in the first place? This is still a glaring error that the show has not addressed.
As this season already proves, the essential problem of Glee is that it represents excess. The show is too much. Too campy, too showy, too loud. There is too much homosexuality, too much overacting and too much music. The secret political messages are excessive and just plain wrong. The whole “arts education” agenda is off track with mainstream America. We don’t want to be told that musical choir is more important than competitive athletics in high school life. It’s not decent and it’s not fair. Where are the dissenting opinions? This show does not allow for freedom of speech, no one is given an opportunity to present an alternative to the lust and sex and immorality. Glee presents only a single view of high school life, a very slanted and opinionated view that does not permit Christian values or America decency to peek in. This could be why the producers are so comfortable around the actors’ weight gain, because maybe in their minds being muscled and sporty has no relevance to the careers in the arts that this show is secretly trying to promote through glee club.
http://newsbusters.org/blogs/colleen-raezler/2010/04/14/glee-coach-knocks-sarah-palin-stupid
- Excited
- Fascinated
- Amused
- Bored
- Sad
- Angry





oh coem on a didn’t we discus this piece of shit to death? where are you getting´you reatdet facts? like what worried parents? as i remeber it what happened was that you claimed it SHOULD worry parents then about 10-20 people agreed with you whille the article itself was spread to further redicule it. i’m sorry but this show isn’t christian and it’s not ment to be therefore dismissing it based on it’s lack of christian values is like dismisiing the bible based on it’s lack of atheist values or muslim values.
further more just because you personally don’t understand the premise of a show and don’t like it doesn’t mean that it’s bad. i don’t understand the bible and i find it broing…did i just prove you are wrong or that the bible is bad?
Hot debate. What do you think?
21
17
Thanks for the question, Jazzy! Yes my first report on Glee did draw a lot of attention. I think many parents didn’t realize just how radical this show was. It seems simple and fun, but the truth is issues like abortion, suicide, drugs and gay sex are just not appropriate for young children and this show genuinely crosses the line.
Hot debate. What do you think?
11
42
Stephen, once again I must remind you you’re not a Christian and you’re not going to heaven, but beyond that, why is it so bad for a TV show to show the realities of what kids face in their daily lives.
Teen suicide, gay teens being harassed (by bigot’s like you), obesity and teen pregnancies are all realities.
I know you think somewhere out there is a Utopic world that will live by every word of the bible, but lets face it, you cannot even do it.
You are sad man, truly sad man.
Well-loved. Like or Dislike:
51
4
For someone who is definitely not a homosexual, you certainly have a preoccupation with the slight weight gain of the handsome male lead. I mean, an entire section about it?
Anyway, you’re once again taking a swing at the lowest-hanging fruit on the market. I mean, why not write a screed about why Satanism is wrong next? We all know that Glee is gently subversive and quite entertainingly madcap; we are quite aware that there is a pseudo-sympathetic homosexual character. You are offering nothing new here. Why should we read this when we already are aware of it?
Well-loved. Like or Dislike:
33
1
Woddy, as a former high school athlete I am keenly aware of the importance of sports when you’re young. They build great social skills as well as keeping young people fit and trim. This is vital today and it’s one of those things that makes America great! If our young men can’t compete on the football field, what chance do they have in business or the military?
Hot debate. What do you think?
4
39
stephinson sure seems to think about them locker scenes alot , i bet he missed them
Praise or Condemn:
8
1
What in the world does playing sports have to do with being a business man??? And in some fields of the military (nuclear power) most guys are scrawny geeks who sit on their ass playing dungeons and dragons. The show is not intended for little kiddies so sure they might not get some of the jokes. Abortion, politics, and sexuality are a part of what goes on in the world. Parents should sit down with there kids and have these discussions. Sheltering kids makes them clueless, ignorant, and dumb to society around them. The show is for entertainment purposes only. This is not a self help show that teaches you how to run your life. Furthermore you should stop downing the entertainment industry. People can make good money working behind the scenes. So what if the main character puts on weight ? People do all the time, I mean look at yourself. The character is clearly stressed on the show, stress can lead to eating, and eating can lead to weight gain. Frankly if you don’t like the show don’t watch it. Stop trying to inform parents on why it is so bad when you clearly don’t know what your talking about. Let parents decide if they should let their Teens watch the show and encourage parents to explain abortion and other related topics you seem to hate so much
Praise or Condemn:
4
1
You’re one to talk about chubbiness. Have you looked in the mirror recently? Oh, wait, you’re too busy cramming cheeseburgers and ice cream in your mouth to get up off your fat ass. Hypocrite.
Hey Billings, if you had a girlfriend she could use you as a mattress…although she’d have to roll over five times just to get off.
Well-loved. Like or Dislike:
38
2
claire could you ever imagine him with a girlfriend let alone ever having sex with one?? wait oh fucking god i had to get an image of it in my head!!!……. right im gonna go get a cricket bat and hit myself with it till the image is gone
Praise or Condemn:
19
5
“Fear thou not; for I am with thee: be not dismayed; for I am thy God: I will strengthen thee; yea, I will help thee; yea, I will uphold thee with the right hand of my righteousness.” –Isaiah 41:10.
Hot debate. What do you think?
6
24
“I digitally replaced Jabba the Hutt in the new Star Wars film! Whateva, I’ll do what I want!” – Eric Cartman
Hot debate. What do you think?
25
5
“Sell everything you possess and give the money to the poor.”
–Luke 18:22
Everyone, post this whenever Billings throws down a bible verse. Then take a shot.
Praise or Condemn:
19
5
Whenever I hear another Palin joke, I remember just how terrified Palin makes Liberals. And I always have to wonder how ANYONE can call Palin stupid after voting this jackass into the White House.
Who’s running the country? Palin or Obama?
In the last 16 months, who has done more to bring record deficits, record unemployment, record bank failures, record spending, record corruption, record foreign policy disasters, and record speed of destruction of the dollar and US standing in the world? Palin or Obama?
Stupid Liberals.
Hot debate. What do you think?
7
49
see this is the funny thing….we don’t actually agree on whats right and wrong…. from our point of view obama has been doing at least decently whille palin has been actively destorying the world….is that a good enough ansver?
Hot debate. What do you think?
29
7
Seriously? Obama was left to deal with Bush’s mess.
Praise or Condemn:
18
6
LeAnn, first off you’re not a christian and you’re not going to heaven.
You don’t get a free pass blaming the economy on Obama. Bush had a balanced budget and a $250 billion surplus of cash in January of 2001. In January of 2009 he left us with a $1.3 trillion deficit and in those nine years he took the debt from 4 trillion to 9 trillion. Those are the facts, you don’t get a free pass.
The first bailout happened in 2008 under Bush, almost 900 Billion to be exact, but you fake Christians have amnesia, you only remember the second bailout under Obama.
Bush never vetoed one spending bill under the GOP controlled congress from 2001 to 2006. Once again, you don’t get a free pass.
You fell for his lies of WMD’s, he lied, over 5000 brave Americans are now dead, countless of innocent Iraqi’s are dead too, some estimate over 100K.
You don’t get a pass.
You are not a Christian because a Christian is not suppose to lie, your entire life is one big lie
You don’t get a free pass
Praise or Condemn:
23
6
everything start By bush yet stupid republican still think is Obama yes he is Inexperienced but if it’s was McCain and Palin as bice they would have waged 2-3-4 More wars for what reason Religion??? Peace ??? Freedom ????
Greediness is the first reason for every american to attack any countries outside their border
On a Side note Billings : do You think the guys with hairy chest should at least shave his chest it’s really Ugly I means he Looks Like a Bear
Praise or Condemn:
10
6
“resulting in Christwire’s advisory report, “What Every Parent Should Know About The TV Show Glee,” which was widely distributed across the world wide web.”
To the laughs of millions.
“Most parents seemed concerned that Glee was promoting homosexuality, atheism and careers in the arts while dismissing Christianity and traditional athletics.”
More like YOU were concerned about those things. And fuck athletics. As much as I dislike art, I’d much rather be an artist than a testosterone-riddled jock who’s brain is so fried from steroids that he can’t even determine right from left. There’s a reason why “jock” sounds so similar to “jerk”.
“Lesbian Sue Sylvester mocked Vice Presidential candidate Sarah Palin by calling her “stupid.””
Oh, heaven forbid someone should call a political figure “stupid”. In the words of Dr. McCoy, “My god man!”
“Critics were outraged, pointing out that it was highly inappropriate to introduce secret political messages in a children’s show.”
The show is for teenagers, not children. Teenagers are old enough to make their own political decisions.
“For the most part, it lacks a plot.”
A real journalist wouldn’t underline things that they view as important. That just makes you seem desperate.
“The camera focuses on various young men, some ethnic”
Why did you feel the need to point out that some of them were ethnic? Yes, we have non-white people in America! Get over it!
“reaching out to grab their bare bodies.”
We can see the words “bare bodies” perfectly fine without you putting them in bold.
“He gyrates his pelvis in alluring ways as if begging the young men of America to rub up against their television screens in passion and sympathy.”
I highly doubt that rubbing up against their televisions was on the minds of American men. I’ve pretty sure that you’re the only one who thinks men may have been enticed to make love to their television sets.
“Both supporters and detractors alike were surprised to see the actors on this show return with bloated, haggard looks.”
They most certainly can’t have looked as bad as you do every single day, Billings.
“He has lost his grace and surely there will be no shower scenes this season featuring a bare-chested Finn.”
Aww, it’s okay, I’m sure that there will be plenty of other teenage boys on the show for you to ogle.
“How realistic is it to have a Jewish character in Ohio in the first place?”
Are you fucking kidding me? How stupid are you?
From http://www.ohiohistorycentral.org/entry.php?rec=600 :
“Jews lived in Ohio from the state’s creation in 1803…Thousands more Jews arrived in Ohio during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries…With the creation of Israel following this conflict, many Jewish people, including many from Ohio, migrated to this new nation. Ohio’s Jewish population, however, remained large and thriving at the start of the twenty-first century. Jewish synagogues and other cultural institutions continue to enhance Ohio life.”
“We don’t want to be told that musical choir is more important than competitive athletics in high school life.”
Why the fuck not? Look asswipe, not every single person in America likes sports. Many people, like myself, DESPISE sports. Loud, competitive, violent, testosterone-addled games may appeal to some people, but not everybody. Last time I checked, artsy students weren’t very likely to suffer a traumatic brain injury while painting a picture and wind up in a wheelchair, going to a special out-of-district school for their new physical disability. My mom works for the city at the Office of Special Education, arranging transportation for students with mental, developmental, and physical disabilities. She’s seen way too many cases of students who can no longer move their lower bodies, or are even fully paralyzed, thanks to sports, particularly football.
Well-loved. Like or Dislike:
53
1
Poor, misguided Claire… as an expert on health and sports I must heartily disagree with your claims and advise parents everywhere to do likewise. Sports are integral to mental and physical health. I am truly sorry to hear about the disabled boy (that is awful sad!), but you cannot ban sports on that incident alone. There are pads and helmets and proper athletic procedures that must be followed. In fact, learning to play by the rules is another essential part of the jock life. It does teach children to have a code and shows them that faith in a code is crucial to human success. This is why so many high school athletes go on to achieve so much in life! Especially compared to all those kids who sat around with finger paints and their bong hits, still working on that first novel as they live in some inner-city rental apartment with a group of lazy girls. I had a friend in high school that did just that. Sadly, he came from a home without much Christian teaching and although he had a strongly sculpted body with nice natural muscles crested by a touch of downy hair and would have made a great football player (believe me, the coach did try!) but instead he wanted to hang out in parking lots drinking whiskey and smoking cigarettes. Well, as you can imagine his mother lost her job and when the family got real broke, he just picked up his bags and moved to New Orleans (of all places!) leaving his old buddies behind without a phone call or letter, and down there in New Orleans he worked in a fancy restaurant and met all sorts of slick city people and was bragging about art shows and trips to Mexico and some rich older man from Florida he was spending time with and who knows what sort of trouble he got into and he never came back to see his Mom though he’d call her on the weekends and I even asked after him whenever I saw his Mom in the grocery and well the story goes that he’s turned into some bohemian artist down there living in a small apartment with some French guys and even though it was thirty years ago it still stings. Well, I never did see Carl again though I wish I had his address so I could send him a Bible or drop by for a visit if I ever make it down there.
Praise or Condemn:
3
24
“as an expert on health”
[img]http://duckydees.50g.com/ROTFL2.gif[/img]
“but you cannot ban sports on that incident alone.”
Nowhere did I say that sports should be banned. All I’m saying is that there are much more important things in life than violent, competitive games, and kids should not be forced into sports.
“although he had a strongly sculpted body with nice natural muscles crested by a touch of downy hair”
Did you blow a wad on the computer screen as you typed that, you sicko?
“Well, as you can imagine his mother lost her job and when the family got real broke, he just picked up his bags and moved to New Orleans (of all places!) leaving his old buddies behind without a phone call or letter, and down there in New Orleans he worked in a fancy restaurant and met all sorts of slick city people and was bragging about art shows and trips to Mexico and some rich older man from Florida he was spending time with and who knows what sort of trouble he got into and he never came back to see his Mom though he’d call her on the weekends and I even asked after him whenever I saw his Mom in the grocery and well the story goes that he’s turned into some bohemian artist down there living in a small apartment with some French guys and even though it was thirty years ago it still stings.”
Ever heard of a period or a comma?
“Well, I never did see Carl again though I wish I had his address so I could send him a Bible or drop by for a visit if I ever make it down there.”
Why, so you can tell him that he’s living his life wrong? Did it ever occur to you that perhaps he likes the way he lives? As I’ve said before, NOT EVERYBODY LIKES SPORTS.
Well-loved. Like or Dislike:
29
1
I thought I’d share a story of my childhood. Thanks for being so kind in your response. That really hurts, Claire. I have worried after this old friend for some time. You are just cold and cruel, a monster with no emotions who only lusts for more debauchery in this world. You are a major disappointment to me today my friend.
Hot debate. What do you think?
5
25
“That really hurts, Claire.”
Hmm, I recall you chastising another person a while back for not having a “thick skin”.
“You are just cold and cruel, a monster with no emotions who only lusts for more debauchery in this world.”
Whatever your twisted mind wants to believe.
“You are a major disappointment to me today my friend.”
I’m not your friend.
Well-loved. Like or Dislike:
30
1
I wanted to open my heart and let out some of my life, my treasures from the past, and you have no interest. You are a tough one, I’m sure you’ll make your future husband cry.
Praise or Condemn:
4
20
“Sell everything you possess and give the money to the poor.”
–Luke 18:22
Praise or Condemn:
10
3
Mr. Stephenson Billings,
If you as Conservative Christian as you say you are, why are you lying in these two articles about Glee? I’m honestly asking.
You obviously have not seen any episodes of Glee.
I myself, am a Conservative Christian. Explain to me, please.
Praise or Condemn:
8
2
“How realistic is it to have a Jewish character in Ohio in the first place? This is still a glaring error that the show has not addressed.”
Annie Oakley is from Ohio, and she is Jewish.
Praise or Condemn:
2
0
Are you seriously confusing Jane Lynch with Madonna?
Well-loved. Like or Dislike:
44
3
thank you for saying that! that’s exactly what i was thinking – i kept saying to myself, “no, I must be misinterpreting this. There’s no way someone would actually think that was Madonna in the ep…!!”
Praise or Condemn:
11
0
ohhh i was hoping someone was gonna point out it is jane lynch and not madonna in the vogue video scene lol
Praise or Condemn:
7
1
Thank you! The idiot writing this piece of trash article can’t even tell the difference between Jane Lynch and Madonna, although he appears to think he’s an expert on the latter as he claims to know about her personal living situation and number of employees in her home. The other line that really got me was that Vogue was made famous by the Devil Wears Prada…more like the other way around. The only reason that book became popular and was adapted to be a movie was because it was a tell all about Anna Wintour. Clearly the sad, pathetic man writing this doesn’t know what he’s talking about. I sincerely hope no one takes him seriously.
PS, it isn’t exactly a “secret” political agenda when they shove it in your face.
Praise or Condemn:
10
0
You really have no cause to approach me with such disrespect. I am an adult, with many years of journalistic experience. I think I know a thing or two about facts and American culture. While you may disagree with a few details here and there, you must see the logic of my entire argument that this show Glee is wholly inappropriate for children and sells them the worst types of slimy values. I am saddened, personally, to see that you’d rather embrace the radical side of our culture rather than becoming a good person. Jesus loves you, despite the fact that you want to embrace this peculiar sort of liberal fantasy world. I truly feel sorry for your parents dealing with such an ungrateful child.
Praise or Condemn:
2
11
Logic? Sorry, the thing that struck me most about your article was the glaring lack of logic. Since you are clearly concerned about my faith and family life, you should also know that I’m a Christian. I was also both a high school athlete and involved with the drama club. I attended a top 10 university, I have a great career, and I’m extremely close to my parents and grateful to them for raising me to be an open minded, loving person who can accept those with differing believes and values. What I cannot accept is those who choose to preach injustice, hate, and intolerance in the name of God. You are entitled to your opinions, just as I’m entitled to mine, and I’m grateful that we live in a country that allows everyone the same opportunity to speak their mind. So here I am, speaking my mind. I believe that your article is written with out base, merit, or any form of journalistic credibility. You believe that I’m wrong. Live and let live.
Praise or Condemn:
12
1
Why are liberals like you so full of hate? I am only trying to share love here and help parents save their children from a lifetime of bad choices and you ride along on your high horse shouting that I’m the devil? You seriously need to have that head of yours checked out young lady.
Praise or Condemn:
1
17
You’re making fun of young adults’ weights, hating on gay people, condemning all those who don’t agree with you, accusing kids of partying because they’ve gained a pound or two (you could stand to lose about fifty), and generally just being a dick while (simultaneously spreading your ill-informed religious propaganda)…
and liberals are the hateful ones? But while we’re on the subject of hate, YES LIBERALS HATE YOU. OR AT LEAST I DO. YOU’RE FUCKING STUPID AS HELL. I’M NOT ABOUT TO ‘LIKE’ THAT ON FACEBOOK. Fucking idiot.
Praise or Condemn:
5
0
wow, this is like the stupidest, most ubsurb post I have ever read. If you don’t like the show turn it off. Its not hard. Well, given your knowledge of the world you were probably brought up omish so I bet you don’t know how, so I let that slide. But that still doens’t make it right for you to unfairley critisize the show or its actors (Finn is smokin’ by the way) And it doesn’t have anymore homosexuality in it than any other show on TV today. Ooooh it has one gay character who has like 4 lines per show! My goodness, someone get the bible! Geeze, get a life.
Praise or Condemn:
17
1
I watched about 5 minutes of Glee the other night, and it’s just not my cup of tea. I know I won’t waste my time again. If they dislike me and insult my personal beliefs, why should I watch it? I’m just sick of hearing Gov. Palin insulted for no reason other than it’s a cheap shot and sure sucker punch.
Praise or Condemn:
3
12
I hope all parents reach over their children’s shoulders to turn off this tv show. That is exactly my goal here. CHANGE THAT CHANNEL PEOPLE!
Praise or Condemn:
3
20
My mother watches the show with me and enjoys it very much!
I wonder what would she say reading your article. I guess I’ll link it to her facebook profile tonight.
Praise or Condemn:
11
3
My friend I will gladly speak to your mother about these problems. Please have her send me a note at the email address above and God Bless You!
Praise or Condemn:
5
10
that’s exactly OUR goal here. we don’t like that shitty book. CLOOSE THAT BIBLE IDIOTS!!!!
Praise or Condemn:
16
2
Wow… you missed the point of the show completely.
Praise or Condemn:
23
3
You understand so little, my child.
Hot debate. What do you think?
3
28
Nope Stephenson, YOU are the one who understands so little.
Praise or Condemn:
13
2
Dude, there’s a little button on both your tv and remote. Change the channel!
Praise or Condemn:
10
4
Eat more cheese and pray to God that there’s a Season 3
Praise or Condemn:
12
5
Ha…hahahahahaha…hahahahahahahahahahaha.
Please, please, please someone tell me this a joke…
Praise or Condemn:
17
3
Once again, you have proven just how much of an incompetent asshole you truly are. And, you know, if I didn’t like a show, I don’t think I’d watch it EVERY WEEK. Just a hint.
Actually, thank you for posting this. It gives me something to laugh at, considering what a piece of trash this article (hell, this whole website) really is.
Praise or Condemn:
14
1
Spencer, I am offering my guidance to parents. I am a journalist who focuses on cultural issues from a Christian perspective and I think it’s essential that adults today pay attention to the trouble that their kids are getting into.
Praise or Condemn:
2
11
No, you’re a child molester and pedophile who preys on young boys who aren’t experienced enough to spot your treachery.
Praise or Condemn:
17
5
Oh Fake Adam, you really are a simpleton. You jokes aren’t even worthy anymore.
Praise or Condemn:
3
15
You need to do research and have accurate information to call yourself a journalist. Posting opinions of a television show on a website with a Christian bias (not saying that anything is wrong with Christianity; I am an extremely devout Christian) does not make you a journalist.
God have mercy on your soul. It’s a good thing being wrongly entitled isn’t a sin.
Praise or Condemn:
5
0
I just think your a dude with an opinion, This show personally has saved me in a way. I work at a freaking CHURCH, this show does nothing wrong to any body, im not going to get fat just because I see a fatter girl on TV? So knock it off. Your missing the point of the show.
Glee is about opening yourself up to joy
Praise or Condemn:
20
0
I am done with Glee. Was a fun show but now it is just another attempt to indoctrinate the mindless and ‘gleeful’ masses with the writers’ own sordid version of planet earth. Go forth children and fornicate! Life is hard enough for the youthful to get right without this sort of influence. So guess what kids – you are being set-up – it’s not normal just because THEY say so!
Praise or Condemn:
2
11
so… i have a problem with this article for a few reasons. one, a lot of the things you talk about didn’t actually happen. two, sue sylvester the character is not a lesbian, the actress who plays her is, believe it or not, there is a difference. 3. lea michele (rachel berry) does all of her own singing- she was on broadway, where it is impossible to dub voices. the lip synching is part of having music on film. 4. there are jewish people in every state. why can’t there be a jewish girl in ohio? is it because ohio is in the midwest? well, i’m from minnesota, and guess what? i’m jewish. 5. this show isn’t saying that athletics are bad, it is saying that the arts are important, too. not everyone can be a star athlete; what are these kids supposed to do? learning about music and art is a good thing, and, as this show tells us, the arts and athletics are not mutually exclusive.
thank you for your time.
Praise or Condemn:
18
1
Hi Sam, here are my answers to your questions!
2) Sue Sylvester is a lesbian. This clearly comes across from her performance on tv. She is a hard, cold woman who spend too much time inserting herself into the lives of young women.
3) The Jewish girl Rachel’s singing on that episode I mentioned was clearly, sadly fake. I don’t know anything about Broadway shows but it’s interesting to see you are spending time obsesses with such things instead of your studies. If she was such a good singer, why didn’t they have her sing without the heavy redubbing? Your point has no merit.
4) Ohio has been traditionally known as a Christian state and a very strong one at that! If you are some sort of ethnic pioneer, well good for you. I have nothing against the Jewish people though I do have issues with the state of Israel and what certain people of that persuasion are doing to Hollywood. Sometimes Seinfeld make me chuckle so you’re not all bad.
5) As a former high school athlete, I think I know full well what this show is trying to promote in its subversive ways. It is wrong and saying that show choir is a worthwhile thing to spend your time on is just dangerously misleading. These things don’t help you get into college and they don’t prepare you for the huddles and tackles of real world life. I am sorry about that, but it’s the truth! The truth can be hard, believe me.
Blessings on you,
Stephenson
Praise or Condemn:
2
23
But kicking an American football…football makes you able to tackle real life problems? Get screwed as far as im concerned.
“The truth can be hard, believe me.”
You arn’t very willing to accept that Jesus and the magical astro wizard don’t exist, and you must be about 50-60 ATLEAST…hence you have no room to say what is and isn’t the truth.
Praise or Condemn:
10
2
“She is a hard, cold woman who spend too much time inserting herself into the lives of young women.”
1. Exactly how does being hard and cold make one a lesbian?
2. You spend too much time inserting yourself into the lives (and orifices) of young men, yet you claim to be heterosexual. What gives?
“It is wrong and saying that show choir is a worthwhile thing to spend your time on is just dangerously misleading.”
Are you high or just incredibly stupid? There is nothing wrong with choir, and there is most certainly nothing dangerous about it. The only difference between choir and athletics is that choir doesn’t involve violence and doesn’t require devolving back to an ape. Choir is about teamwork just as football is.
“These things don’t help you get into college and they don’t prepare you for the huddles and tackles of real world life.”
The only reason why students get sports scholarships is because the colleges know that they will make money for the school. Stop being so fucking arrogant for once and realize that sports aren’t for everybody.
Praise or Condemn:
15
1
Coin, what in the world are you talking about? European sports have always been known to be a bit “fruity” shall we say.
1) Claire, it has come to my attention that this person is a Lesbian in real life, which only underscores my point that she’s playing one on tv. She can’t but help let that side of personality out when she’s on camera. Sad, really.
2) I add am a journalist and a teacher, so it’s my occupation and my calling to educate those who need educating. I’m sorry that this offends you, but the majority of people I meet will thank me later for the comfort and wisdom that I gave them, God willing.
3) Church choirs are a beautiful thing and they’re a fun way to take part in the community of Christ. That said, singing groups like the one depicted on this show have zero to do with Christianity and everything to do with narcissicism and sexual experimentation. I just find that wrong and offensive. They celebrate homosexuality and poorly formed young bodies. The children who watch this show are being misled into thinking they’re being decent and good by being an artist when most artists are PERVERTS if I can speak frankly. Yes, these people grow up to embrace liberalism and vote for Obama because they want no rule of law and want the government to pay for health care so they can do bong hits and have sex with anybody and anything that crosses their paths. I don’t know why you support this agenda, but it’s not my America, thank you very much.
5) Sports are just fantastic. Anyone who has played will surely tell you that. My high school football games were some of the most wonderful highlights of my life and it sickens me that you spit on that. You are the definition of a “hater” while I bring armfuls of love and hope to children daily.
Praise or Condemn:
3
16
Wow, I have never seen a bigger closet case ever. That line about your buddy earlier was pretty telling, this projection onto Sue Sylvester is even better.
You’re projecting your own homosexual feelings onto a fictional character. Of course she spends lots of time around young girls… shes a cheerleader coach! Your football coach spent a lot of time around young boys and men. He must have been a huge faggot.
Praise or Condemn:
14
1
“singing groups like the one depicted on this show have zero to do with Christianity and everything to do with narcissicism and sexual experimentation.”
1. Why should they have a single thing to do with Christianity? Has it occurred to you that not every American is a Christian? Are you aware that in America we have the freedom to worship what and who we want?
2. You’re one to talk about narcissism. Or, as you put it, “narcissicism”.
3. Sexual experimentation? Where’s you proof?
“The children who watch this show are being misled into thinking they’re being decent and good by being an artist when most artists are PERVERTS if I can speak frankly.”
Have you, uh, barked at the moon recently, Billings?
“Sports are just fantastic.”
Some agree with you, some don’t.
“My high school football games were some of the most wonderful highlights of my life and it sickens me that you spit on that.”
I’m sure that most students who were in the choir feel just as sickened that you spit on their choice of a talent.
Praise or Condemn:
20
0
Seriously? I am horrible at sports, and i felt horrible about that for a while. I have been bullied by jocks like you my whole life so for you and your kind FUCK YOU!
Praise or Condemn:
1
0
You should try harder.
Praise or Condemn:
1
2
Seriously? I have tried. I’ve played basketball, baseball, and soccer, and I got made fun of for trying. THAT is what sports promotes. It promotes being a musclebound jerk and mocking those whose talents may lie in more creative or academic directions. Yes I’ll say that it does promote teamwork, but only if your teammates are good. If not, then you’re just joke fodder. Frankly, my response to jocks who make fun of me for being smart, creative, or gay is “Well, you’ll be working for me someday.
Praise or Condemn:
0
0
Actually… after looking around this site some more, bravo. I rescind my comments
Praise or Condemn:
0
7
I seriously can’t believe I’m typing a comment to this article, but I just can’t resist. You, sir, are the poor, misguided one. Every single thing you wrote about on here raised red flags for me, but it’s really the weight-gain comments that gets me. WHO ARE YOU to judge these people? What is WRONG with you? Why do you feel the need to point out that there’s a Jew living in Ohio, and why did you feel the need to mention that some of the guys in the video are “ethnic”? You need to talk more to my God, one that is loving, merciful, and forgiving, no matter how un-perfect we are.
Have a great day!!
Also, I think you need to go back and watch ALL of the episodes of this show. You can go to Fox on demand (yes, people can watch the show ONLINE and not just on the television! Oh, the horror!) and watch every single episode there. I think you are really missing the point of the show. It’s a show that recognizes that not everyone is a jock or loves sports…it’s a show that makes people who are a little different feel better about themselves.
One more comment before I go…I am an artist and the way you speak about the art world offends me. I love art because it has helped me to find a part of me that I never would have found before. Art is the way I, personally, express myself.
I hope you find your happy place soon so you don’t have to judge others.
Praise or Condemn:
11
0
Anna, yes I have indeed watched many of the episodes of this show, pencil in hand to take notes. So you see there’s no reason for me to go back and review it. This show is so upsetting I don’t recommend anyone watch it. The perversion of common decency and the oh so subtle homosexual agenda is simply not appropriate.
I strongly believe that high school athletics are essential for developing children. Sports teaches children how to compete and makes them appreciate their strengths, physical and mental. It is important for children to be active, to run and play. Unfortunately this whole arts education thing has taken valuable funding away from sports. Arts are fun, but they don’t contribute anything to a child’s physical or mental state. If we had more money in the economy I could see spending it on such extra-curriculums, but no with how much this country is suffering. And this is the reason why I am highlighting the weight gain issues. It’s just not right that they promote this sort of lifestyle on national tv.
Praise or Condemn:
4
10
“I strongly believe that high school athletics are essential for developing children.”
Bullshit.
“Sports teaches children how to compete”
There’s already enough competition in our society!
“It is important for children to be active, to run and play.”
Yes, but sports aren’t the only vehicles for that.
“Arts are fun, but they don’t contribute anything to a child’s physical or mental state.”
Actually they contribute a lot to a child’s mental state. Art allows kids to work through and express their feelings.
“And this is the reason why I am highlighting the weight gain issues. It’s just not right that they promote this sort of lifestyle on national tv.”
Hello? Are you blind? You’re a tub of lard! A jiggling mass of fat that probably can’t walk one block without having to stop for a breath. Stop being such a goddamned hypocrite, you fatass.
Praise or Condemn:
13
1
Stephenson,
You really are so off base here. I participated in high school sports all throughout my career in school, and while I enjoyed my experiences, it is nothing compared to how I feel whenever I create a work of art. Art is such an important part of our society. Some of my first art history classes taught the importance of art throughout the ages, and specifically how it contributed to the church. Ever admire the sun shining through a beautiful stained glass window? Not only do stained glass windows usually depict the stories you find in the Bible, but they are also considered ART. Stained glass artists were some of the most diligent and hard-working artists during that time, and they were greatly respected because they brought the word of God to the masses who were illiterate or did not have enough money to but the book.
I’ve noticed that this site loves to use statistics and results of studies, so here are some statistics I found from a quick internet search about how art helps brain development and improves scores in schools:
Arts education fosters brain development:
* Scientists used functional MRIs to scan the brains of pianists and non-musicians of the same age and sex. They found that, compared to non-musicians, the brains of pianists are more efficient at skilled movements. (National Association for Music Education)
* University of Montreal researchers used various brain imaging techniques to investigate brain activity during musical tasks and found that sight-reading musical scores and playing music both activate regions in all four of the cortex’s lobes; and that parts of the cerebellum are also activated during these tasks. (National Association for Music Education)
Arts education and the development of social skills:
Catterall notes that instruction in the arts affects social skills including positive social behaviors, social compliance, ability to express emotion, courtesy, tolerance, conflict-resolution skills, ability to collaborate, and attention to moral development. Rauscher suggests that only by working together can students play a musical performance and thus, they learn that cooperation is a means to an end, which can be applied to other goals.
* The Arts Alternatives Program was offered to 4th through 6th grade students in New Jersey urban schools serving disadvantaged students. The program included role-playing and story writing activities. Students reported significantly improved attitudes relating to self-expression, trust, self-acceptance and acceptance of others. (Welch)
* A review of 57 research studies found that self-concept is positively enhanced through the arts. The relationship between music participation and self-concept was strongly in evidence. (Arts Education Partnership).
* 5th grade band students derived satisfaction from peer and adult recognition through their band experience regardless of their perception of their talents. (Arts Education Partnership)
* Texas secondary school students who participated in band, orchestra or choir reported the lowest lifetime incidence of substance abuse. (Children’s Music Workshop).
* ‘With music in schools, students connect to each other better – greater camaraderie, fewer fights, less racism and reduced use of hurtful sarcasm.” (Support Music.com)
* Two studies among elementary school students receiving training in the Kodaly Music program which builds skills in individual and group singing found that students receiving more extensive Kodaly training showed greater improvements in classroom behavior and standardized reading scores. (Gardiner)
I would like to highlight some of the words we see above, specifically the next to last bullet point: With music (arts) in schools, students CONNECT to each other better- greater CAMARADERIE, fewer FIGHTS, less RACISM, and reduced use of HURTFUL SARCASM.
There are so many other studies and statistics that promote arts and music in schools. I am not saying that sports should be done away with, I don’t really have a problem with sports. But if we want our youth to grow into well-rounded and well-adjusted members of society, we cannot cut them short by saying “Arts are fun – but they don’t contribute to a child’s physical or mental health..” because that, my friend, just is not true.
Please, I would love to hear your response to this argument.
PS: CLAIRE, keep up the good fight, sister.
Praise or Condemn:
15
1
Anna,
he’s not going to respond to your post, because whenever somebody writes a good rebuttal to the diarrhea that comes out of his mouth, he runs away with his tail between his legs and simply never replies.
Of course, he could just do like the other conservative nutjobs on here do when they need an easy way out and claim that your sources are from “liberal” organizations/websites and are therefore invalid.
And you keep up the good fight, too. We’ll have Billings in a straight jacket and a padded room in no time.
Praise or Condemn:
14
1
Anna, you clearly are the exception to the rule. Sports are so key to combatting the epidemic of obsiety and apathy crushing our children today. If it wasn’t for the tv and the internet, sports might have a fighting chance. Art only makes it worse. Kids today are skipping sports by signing up for computer or art classes (or even worse, computer graphic design classes). And don’t get me started on the danger of video games!
Much art is decadent and it is symbolic of a society on the decline, that coddles the sexually permiscuous, the aesthetes and the collectors. I just don’t that’s fair or right. The Renaissance, a depth of Catholic depravity if there ever was one, went clearly too far in embracing artistic license. The Vatican is covered in nudity and homosexual paintings. I do not approve and that is one of the main causes of the Reformation, when Luther and others broke off from the church because of its pomp and circumstance. The Bible is very clear about homosexuals!
As for your scientific studies, I must admit that I have not encountered them before but I should caution you against believing whatever garbage you find on Google. There is too much bunk science distributed out there, particularly by the liberal elite who have their own secret agendas. There are especially concerned with getting federal funds sent their way for perverse and wasteful projects and for employing the unemployable. It really is sad when you think how low this country has sunk.
Well, thank you Anna for keeping an open mind and I am sorry to disprove your argument but I feel the truth is vital in these times. It’s people like Obama keeping this country off track and keeping the focus on making Americans the best they can be. Socialism in Europe and the Soviet Union placed a high regard on art and look where it got them! They have not invented anything worthwhile to society for 500 years while America is the leader in everything and anything. I do believe the righeousness of the US of A while surface again once we accept that we are a Christian nation and that all these perverts are just destroying us because of their intense libidos and that at some point we really need to put our foot down and say No! to all that homosexuality.
Praise or Condemn:
4
11
Claire, it’s so refreshing to have a woman here like Anna who knows how to form complete sentences and a cogent argument. You realy should take a lesson from that girl! And I really hope some day you do reform and kick all those negative attitudes and mean girl habits and start doing something that will make your father proud because you know what? He loves you despite all the wrong things you done.
God bless.
Praise or Condemn:
2
14
WHAT. THE. FUCK? Funding for ARTS education has taken away from “valuable” (read: worthless) funding for sports? Frankly, I would love to go to a school where there are no sports, but that won’t happen. So, I’ll settle for a school where I can be accepted for who I am. That is what glee promotes. I go to a Catholic school, and it sickens me to hear the amount of homophobic comments every day. I get called a “fag” by the very jocks you idolize. I was raised Catholic, but after seeing what the Catholic church says about homosexuality, I swore off of the Catholic church. I have a personal relationship with God. I don’t need a church. For all I care, the Catholic church could get wiped off the face of the earth.
Praise or Condemn:
1
0
The art are as important as sports, if not better
Praise or Condemn:
0
0
I just feel the need to share a few things. I have read both articles and laughed out loud the entire time. I am seventeen, turning eighteen in just over a month. This show is my favorite show, and also my mother’s favorite. She’s fifty-five. This show is designed for teenagers and adults. It is not a children’s show as you;re making it out to be. Now, there are so many things I could say, but one stands out particularly and greatly angers me.
“On the topic of the Jewish girl Rachel, her lack of singing ability was made painfully clear with the awkward lip-synching in the first episode of the season. The voice pumped through America’s tv speakers didn’t even sound close to hers.”
Have you ever seen Lea Michele on Broadway? Have you ever heard her sing live? She was born with a near-perfect voice. She has been on Broadway since age eight. She is hands-down the best singer on the show, followed by Kevin McHale (Artie. The boy in the wheelchair. And if you don’t believe that he is really singing, listen to anything that’s them performing live. Dianna and Cory don’t have very nice live singing voices, but Lea and Kevin do.)
Also, you keep insisting that sports and fitness are more important than the arts. I did gymnastics until the sixth grade. (Private lessons. Not a group class, just one on one with a trainer.) Since then I have not participated in sports at all. I have however found my place in the arts. I’m in drama, I work on the school paper, I sing, and most importantly I’m fully invested in our television production program. Are you really saying that people involved in sports would have better chances of getting into college then I would? (I’m sorry if that’s a reference to your other article about Glee, I read them both consecutively so they sort of just blended together.) A lot of the athletes in my school don’t have a chance of getting into college, but a student in the television production program with me just got accepted into NYU and has a full scholarship. So tell me, how is athletics better than the arts?
Also, a lot of the “facts” you have about Glee are completely untrue. Next time check your facts before writing an article about it. That is the first thing we learned in journalism.
Praise or Condemn:
16
0
Miah, you’re a bit young to be making these big decisions all on your own. I really think you should talk over your tv and social habits with your Mom or your pastor before you do anything dangerous.
As for Rachel, everyone asks me if I’ve seen her on Broadway. No, I have no interest and somehow I doubt you’ve seen her, too. You’re just parroting what your other bloggers have said. This is ridiculous. I don’t care if you BELIEVE she can sing, that episode makes it obvious that she has some problem or another. I miss the old days when tv was live and the singers original. You’re probably too young but we used to have a show called Lawrence Welk that was 100% real! And it was fantastic! The outfits, the tunes, the smiling faces!
And there are many, many sports scholars out there! They grow up to be our leaders, our politicians, our heads of industry, our preachers! None of these gymnastics garbage, you can’t sell me those myths kiddo.
Praise or Condemn:
2
12
“And there are many, many sports scholars out there!”
Yes, we all know about your unhealthy obsession with under-age athletes. Riddle me this though, Billings. Will American Football players all go to Hell? Lev. 11:6-8 states that touching the skin of a dead pig makes you unclean. Could it be you’ve been worshipping adolescent Satanists all this time?
Praise or Condemn:
11
2
“Miah, you’re a bit young to be making these big decisions all on your own.”
What “big decisions”? The decision to be in the drama club, work on the school paper, etc? The decision to watch “Glee”? She’ll be 18 in a month, you dumbass. That’s not too young to be making such decisions.
“I really think you should talk over your tv and social habits with your Mom or your pastor before you do anything dangerous.”
What makes you think she has a pastor?
Praise or Condemn:
14
0
Mia, please don’t let older girls like Claire peer pressure you into bad lifestyle decisions. She has a chip on her shoulder and hates to learn so best to steer clear of her! You have your whole life ahead of you so keep the straight and narrow and you will make a man happy some day. Graduation is coming close and you’ll soon be ready to date boys. I know that will be an exciting time for you!
Praise or Condemn:
3
12
I hate to break it to you, but I really think you know nothing about what life is like for teenagers. Firstly, the time is not approaching for me to date boys. I’ve had plenty of boyfriends in my life. (And before you ask, no, just because I have boyfriends does not mean I’ve been having sex. And I have not been inspired by Glee to date. I’ve dated since before this show even came on.)
I do agree with Claire though. What big decisions? The decisions to be involved in after-school activities where I feel welcome and at home? What I watch on television has nothing to do with what I do in my free time. I’ve been doing these things since my freshman year. The show first aired in May my junior year. It has nothing to do with what I do in my free time.
What is this nonsense you are saying about gymnastics being garbage? If you have seen anyone who has one-on-one gymnastics training and does competitions, you would know how much of a sport it truly is.
Oh, and by the way, Claire is right. I don’t have a pastor. I used to, until my pastor had to move (for personal/family reasons) and his replacement makes me feel very uncomfortable.
Praise or Condemn:
14
1
These articles are completely insane first off. You’re trying to create turmoil and turn people off from what is a perfectly family friendly show. Yes they cover a wide range of topics and that is what makes it relatable. Have you never seen 16 and Pregnant? These things do happen in real life. Maybe they don’t occur in whatever hole you live in, but in the real world…shit happens.
“you will make a man happy some day.”
And wtf is this? Way to be a sexist pig. Like a girls only goal in life is to make a man happy. HA! You’re clearly still living in the 50′s and you need to get in check with society. Kthanks.
Miah, love youu!
Praise or Condemn:
10
0
Art doenst develop anything … You smoked something its develop creativity and your economy suffer because of Mister Bush who was a cocksucker like every or almot every republican
and you said everyone should be a Jock and going into the shower altogether and whipping each other with wet towel ? am I right Billings thats sound Gay at least artist express themselve and there is a Lot of art even In religion
Praise or Condemn:
7
1
You really are the sad face of our public school system with your lack of logic, misspelled words and corrupt grammar. I’m so sorry.
Praise or Condemn:
3
9
“You really are the sad face of our public school system with your lack of logic, misspelled words and corrupt grammar.”
Whatever you say, Mr. “Permiscuous”.
Praise or Condemn:
11
5
Claire, the correct spelling is “promiscuous”.
Praise or Condemn:
6
8
Look a few posts up and you’ll see THIS sentence of YOURS, with the incorrect spelling of promiscuous:
“Much art is decadent and it is symbolic of a society on the decline, that coddles the sexually permiscuous…”
Praise or Condemn:
15
5
Social comments and analytics for this post…
This post was mentioned on Twitter by KatAttak: http://ow.ly/1Byta wow. seriously, a terrible review. #glee…
Praise or Condemn:
3
1
“I wanted to open my heart and let out some of my life, my treasures from the past, and you have no interest.”
Why should I have any interest? You’re a racist, sexist, homophobic bigot.
“I’m sure you’ll make your future husband cry.”
I don’t plan on getting married.
Praise or Condemn:
16
0
Is this article a joke? I think Sue Sylvestor wrote it, because this is the most bigoted, biased, and narrow minded piece of ‘journalism’ I have ever had the displeasure of reading. It terrifies me that people would read this and agree with the points made. Just so you know, because we are Americans we are guaranteed the right to free speech -which includes this article- as well as the ability to speak out against politicians-including the ever delightful and highly qualified Sarah Palin. There is no way any type of campaign can sue the show, because campaign money was not used to fund it-maybe check your facts first. America is a melting pot of different ethnicities, religions, races, genders,sexual orientations,viewpoints, and interests. That characterizes us as a nation and makes us so strong. But if you disagree, maybe you can ask the third reich for pointers, and we can get rid of everyone who is different. Furthermore, the show won an Emmy so I think they are doing something correctly. The episode in discussion also had a strong plot line-including the empowerment of women and developing relations between the shows main characters, but perhaps the writer was too busy viewing the episode through blinders to notice. I also particularly noted how the writer made sure to point out that the ‘bad singer’ was a Jew. Are the two some how related? Please refer back to my third reich comment. Also, no one on the show is overweight, and if they look a little pale maybe because is because theyre busting their asses 18 hours a day to produce the show which you then proceeded to tear apart. I would further like to note that no where in this episode does Madonna herself actually appear, so you are wrong again.
Praise or Condemn:
11
1
I think the people are angry about this show in the same way that they are angry with the gov’t and are organizing in the Tea Party movement. The push behind it all is the growing realization of too much Government and unconstitutional mandates and the general lowering of moral standards across all media. Homosexuality and socialism are just not right for America. I’ve been saying for many years that Libertarian is the way to go back in the days when we were called nut cases. Now the people are finally waking up to that idea but what galls me is they act like it’s something new when we’ve been beating our gums out warning others of the dangers of big government and liberalism for years. Personally, I was a Ron Paul supporter, and he is Libertarian in heart but ran on the Republican ticket the next time to get noticed. I did not like that part, but lets face it. If we are a society that keeps vacillating between Burger King and McDonalds instead of trying something new, then I guess Ron Paul decided to become one of them so that people would see him.
Praise or Condemn:
1
6
I’m glad one of the women in here knows what she’s talking about!
Praise or Condemn:
4
9
“Sports are so key to combatting the epidemic of obsiety and apathy crushing our children today.”
Look everybody, the boar is preaching to us about obesity!
“Art only makes it worse.”
Art is an avenue for children to become creative, make beautiful things, and express their feelings.
“Kids today are skipping sports by signing up for computer or art classes (or even worse, computer graphic design classes).”
That’s because NOT ALL KIDS LIKE SPORTS.
“that coddles the sexually permiscuous”
Are you aware that there’s no such word as “permiscuous”?
“There is too much bunk science distributed out there, particularly by the liberal elite”
Just as I predicted you would do – weasel your way out of forming an intelligent rebuttal to the studies by blaming it on the “liberal elite”.
“and I am sorry to disprove your argument”
You didn’t disprove anything, you arrogant bastard.
Praise or Condemn:
12
0
Fat jokes are just pathetic, Claire. I can’t help but be who I am and my weight really does not concern you.
Did you know that both Hitler and John Wayne Gacy were self-professed artists?
Praise or Condemn:
1
11
“Fat jokes are just pathetic”
Don’t be like that! She’s got a point. You’re in no position to be commenting on others obesity.
Praise or Condemn:
9
2
“I can’t help but be who I am”
Wrong. You could go on a diet.
“and my weight really does not concern you.”
Then why does the weight of an actor on “Glee” concern you? Why does the sexual orientation of people you don’t even know concern you?
Praise or Condemn:
12
1
“Rise in the presence of the aged, show respect for the elderly and revere your God. I am the LORD.” –Leviticus 19:32.
Those are some pretty grand and wise words! Heed them my children and you will learn much from my years of experience.
Praise or Condemn:
3
9
“Sell everything you possess and give the money to the poor.” –Luke 18:22
Praise or Condemn:
10
1
respect is not a right it’s earned. and so far you have done nothing what so ever to earn ours. what you have earned is at best our pitty and at worst our wrath.
Praise or Condemn:
9
2
actually i read a bit more into this.
billings allways talk about how he loved his years as an athlete. he also talks about how we should learn from his expirience. he got fat. he was an athlete.
this means athlets get fat.
wanna be healthy? don’t become an athlete.
thanks billings you just proved us right athletes suck.
Praise or Condemn:
10
0
“Claire, it’s so refreshing to have a woman here like Anna who knows how to form complete sentences and a cogent argument.”
Give me some examples of where I have NOT formed coherent sentences, you sexist asswipe.
“He loves you despite all the wrong things you done.”
And exactly what are these “wrong things” that I’ve done? If keeping my virginity, staying away from drugs and alcohol, not dressing like a whore, and studying instead of partying are all wrong, then I haven’t a clue as to what’s right.
Praise or Condemn:
15
0
Claire, you consistently make no sense, babbling on and on about things that have no relevance and then when you get cornered and scared in a debate, you crack out the fat jokes! That’s very immature and really hurtful, to tell you the truth. Your logic may seem solid in your crazy atheist Cambridge liberal world, but it won’t hold up in heartland America. You have so little faith and soul, your writing scream this out! You have no direction in life. All you want to do is tear down walls, never build up anything! There’s so much you could share and contribute to this world but you spend your days kicking old people in the groin and singing Lady Gaga. I find it such a waste of a promising mind and I do think you have a good head on your shoulders, you’re surely much brighter than the European atheists who visit this board yet are too obsessed with homosexuality and socialism to learn proper grammar… Yet considering all this you are the biggest personal disappointment to me. You’re smart and capable and yet you reject morality and decency to embrace laziness and corruption, facebook and skateboarders… I want to weep for you sometimes.
Praise or Condemn:
2
10
“then when you get cornered and scared in a debate, you crack out the fat jokes!”
Cornered and scared? HAH! You wish! Says the man who throws tantrums and bitches and moans that people are being unfair and “picking on an old man”.
I crack out the fat jokes to give you a taste of your own medicine and to expose your hypocrisy.
“You have no direction in life.”
Really? That’s news to me. Last time I checked, I was busting my ass in school so that I’ll be a Certified Veterinary Technician by 2012.
“There’s so much you could share and contribute to this world but you spend your days kicking old people in the groin and singing Lady Gaga.”
The only old person who I want to kick in the groin is you. And Lady Gaga? I hardly even know who she is!
“yet are too obsessed with homosexuality and socialism to learn proper grammar…”
I’m waiting for an example of my improper grammar.
“Yet considering all this you are the biggest personal disappointment to me.”
Personal? I’d rather not be anything close to personal when it comes to you.
“You’re smart and capable and yet you reject morality and decency to embrace laziness and corruption, facebook and skateboarders… I want to weep for you sometimes.”
You don’t know me at all! I may do facebook, but I’m far from lazy and I hate skateboarders almost as much as I hate you.
Praise or Condemn:
9
3
Claire, don’t let all this get you down. I really am pulling for you! I want you to some day figure out how to live like a wonderful and mature girl that I know you can be! You need a bit of faith and morality right now, and to remove yourself from the hedonism of Cambridge. That place is rather awful, full of derelict liberal drug addicts hanging out in that square, overwhelmed by the liberal elite professors who puff up Obama at every turn, inhabited by the richest Kennedys money can buy who want nothing more than to perpetuate their stranglehold on our culture so that they may rob children blind and steal the innocence of youth.
ps. Adam emailed me recently suggesting I join Facebook. Will you “friend” me if I join up?
Praise or Condemn:
1
13
I’m still waiting for you to tell me what is so wrong with the way I live my life.
Praise or Condemn:
11
1
First off, you are right in assuming that Lea (Rachel) and indeed all of the cast lip-sync the songs during their performances. This is probably what has led you to incorrectly assume that they do not actually sing. The truth is that all the songs are recorded in recording booths, rather than live as it is too much of a demand on the actors to sing the songs perfectly each time, when they may spend several hours filming a sequence.
Secondly, from a Christian perspective, while I can respect attention to the sports, I am surprised at not just your dismissal but complete contempt of the arts. Art has played a significant part in spreading the Christian message, from the icons of the Byzantine period, to the stain-glass windows mentioned above. And surely, if God has given someone the talent to sing, or draw, or dance, isn’t it honouring God to share these gifts?
Praise or Condemn:
9
1
Thank you for being brave enough to apologize.
Praise or Condemn:
1
8
thank you for being brave enough to admit nyou are a homosexual pedophile who kills little girls just because they are not boys you can fucl in the ass.
Praise or Condemn:
8
1
Oh Stephenson Billings. Calm down, Claire darling. You’ll get nowhere with this asshole. He knows, deep down, that you’re right. Glee is my favorite show because it’s optimistic, inspiring, and its main message is about respecting who you are and others around you.How is that wrong?
Praise or Condemn:
8
0
IT IS WRONG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Praise or Condemn:
3
6
Haha See? Poor guy can’t form a coherent response.
Praise or Condemn:
6
4
You’re the one who can’t think. It is obvious to me that my writing style is beyond your third grade education level. Probably too many big words. You don’t understand why this tv show is destroying your soul and frankly that’s sad. May I humbly suggest you talk this issue over your parents and let them decide what’s best for you to be watching, if you should be allowed to watch tv at all. I might add that you sound a tad too young to be on the internet all by yourself without your Mom sitting next to you. I encourage all mothers to sit with their boys as they surf the web. There is too much dangerous information and photographs and it’s not proper parents to leave your kids alone with a computer.
Praise or Condemn:
1
8
And why, pray, shouldn’t it be the FATHERS sitting down with their boys while they’re on the computer?
Praise or Condemn:
7
0
if anything you writing is far to simplistic to be understod. why is it really so hard to belive that rather than us not understanding you, we simply don’t agree?
the bible is also a pile of shit want me to prove it?: WAAAAAH THE BIBLE SUCK, GET IT AWAY I DON’T WANNA KNOW ABAOUT IT!!!! IT SUCKS IT SUCKS IT SUCKS!!!!!!
there we go an argument about as coherent as your own.
Praise or Condemn:
5
0
Stephenson, may I ask how this TV show is destroying my soul? Also, I’m a girl. Just letting you know
Praise or Condemn:
8
0
It is corrupting you, making radical lifestyles seem acceptable and careers in the arts seem attainable. It is taking time away from your school work and making you want to rebel against your loving family. Terrible.
Praise or Condemn:
2
6
if you think that TV can change a persons behaviour that easily and that radicaly you are going to be severly disapointed.
very few people is that impressionable
Praise or Condemn:
1
3
So careers in the arts are unattainable?
Or rather, they were unattainable for you?
Another layer of the rotten onion reveals itself, Billings.
Praise or Condemn:
5
1
Are you out of your mind? This is the most ridiculous load of trash I’ve ever read. 90% of this article is pure speculation and if anyone should be ashamed of influencing audiences it’s you for printing LIES.
Although, I must give you kudos because in this selfless effort to preach to your Christian audience on just how immoral this program is you have to sit thru a grueling 60 minutes of programming. Well sir, God should just shine his light down on you for allowing you to watch so you can further brainwash your audience. I do feel for you and the pain you must feel tainting your pure mind with such filth!
In closing, even if you hate Glee I’m sure you were humming ‘Like a Virgin’ for a good hour the following day. Don’t worry, you don’t have to admit it on the page, it will be our little secret.
Praise or Condemn:
4
3
Amands, thank you for trying to understand my journalism, but I think you really missed the point. You really need a little Jesus in your life to understand why faith can help you overcome all these moral challenges in your life, no matter how young you are! I do have faith that YOU, yes YOU can survive the harassment of perversity on tv and grow up to be a decent human being and a productive member of society. I will pray for you! God bless!
ps. believe me, I have never “hummed” Madonna.
Praise or Condemn:
4
2
Wow. You sure love the phrase “Need a little Jesus in your life,” don’t you, Billings?
Surely you need a lot of Jesus in your life. Or do you mean a tiny little Jesus- like a baby Jesus?
Use better words, Billings. Less childish ones, at least.
Praise or Condemn:
3
3
but that’s exactly the thing billings. most of us manages to overcome this WITHOUT that faith. we do not need it. we are not so weak that we need to belive we have someone looking over us. and it’s fine that some does. that belif is what makes them able to go through life. but it should not be forced on us because we do not need it.
Praise or Condemn:
2
2
you DO know that ohio has two of the largest jewish populations outside of newyork, right? OSU’s hillel has more ppl then my old highschool. columbus ohio also has the second largest sudanese immigrant population, the biggest asian population of the midwest, and a large enough Indian population to support two hindu temples.
and ooh, we have to avoid the arts! the arts are evil! even tho they are a large part of the economy, promote creative thinking, and that not everyone is athletic and therefor doesn’t need to drop 30-40 IQ points from concussions.
I know the world is big and scary and full of evil, but you might want to poke your head out there once in a while.
Praise or Condemn:
3
1
wait is the website for real? I am serious, i cannot figure out if this is an epic joke towards how ridiculous conservative christians are, or if its serious???
either way this made my night, its so ridiculous.
Praise or Condemn:
8
0
I can’t for the life of me figure out if the comments are also satirical or if they actually don’t realize the point of this article and website. Either way– frickin’ hilarious.
Keep up the good work, and keep on spreading the Good Word!!
Praise or Condemn:
1
4
Someone stuck in 1950′s mentality?
Praise or Condemn:
4
0
“abortion, suicide, drugs and gay sex”
Last time I checked, Glee only had drugs in it.
“Lesbian Sue Sylvester”
Jane Lynch, the actress, is a lesbian, not the character.
“Young men, some ethnic”
Yes, they are ethnic. Did you really have to state that?
“How realistic is it to have a Jewish character in Ohio in the first place? This is still a glaring error that the show has not addressed.”
Hmm. VERY realistic? My school in Ohio has 1/3 Jewish community, 1/3 Christian, and 1/3 Muslim, athesist, ect.
“Today, the billionaire performer Madonna has renounced her America citizenship and lives in an English castle with several boys that she adopted from Africa and an extensive crew of servants that services her every whim.”
How do you know she has servants, again?
Please respond.
Praise or Condemn:
4
0
This article is a joke right? I mean it must be a farce- you’re not really an ignorant, homophobic, bigot who is condeming performing arts and actually thought it was Madonna who appeared in the show? People like that don’t really exist but in my nightmares, right???
Praise or Condemn:
4
1
The depth of intelligence you show with your response is a joke.
Praise or Condemn:
1
2
You’re such a fucking ass hole. I’m smarter than you will ever be. And so is everyone here. At least the people who don’t believe your psycho babble bull shit. Go touch yourself, as I’m sure you about to do now at the thought of being persecuted for your “faith”. You make me physically ill with your stupidity and ignorance. Do you really think reading this will make someone want to accept “a little Jesus” in their lives? Fuck no.
Praise or Condemn:
0
0
Stephenson Billings. Conservative Christian. I wonder, since I only discovered this website yesterday, how long ago did you lose your credibility? You claim to be a journalist, rather, you flaunt it, and you use it like a gun. What I see in your writings are tabloids. Is that what you are? A tabloid journalist? Is that what you write? Do you really think that is credible journalism? To write baseless conspiratorial articles, offering no evidence or facts? Do you do ANY research? Or do you sit down, find something that upsets you and start pulling agendas our your ass?
I wonder about you, Billings. You have the air of an extremely repressed homosexual. The way it upsets you so much. The way you go into great poetic detail about the men in television shows who portray homosexuality and their very appearance, even men in your life. It is as though homosexuality is ever present in your mind. You seek it, to expose it, don’t you? Why is it your obsession, I wonder? I wonder if you have these feelings for them, and you are scared, Billings, you are scared because you believe it is wrong. Is it so wrong, Stephenson? How often do you think about those men? How long do you think you have before you become another Jeffrey Dahmer?
Homosexuality is not going to go away. No matter how hard you fight it. It has always been here. It always will be. It is everywhere, ever present, just like your god. You cannot fight it, no matter how big your army is. The only thing you are contributing to is a nasty hateful rift in society. You are contributing to the segregation, the intolerance of the world. You are simply acting as another Fred Phelps. Do you think your god would condone your intolerance or your hate?
As for athletics vs. art. Billings, the world strives on both. However, first, I need to expand your idea of art. Look at the world around you. Artists designed it. Your car was designed by artists. The shape, to both conform to efficiency and aesthetics. Your iPhones, artists came up with them. Your computers, in which you type in your nonsensical ramblings were designed by artists. Everything is art. The arts teaches you and challenges you to use your brain in new ways. To see things subjectively. Without it, we would be followers. Without art, we would still be crucifying people on crosses and living in hovels. Hate it, love it, it doesn’t matter. It still challenges you, and that is the point.
Sports, on the other hand, is the execution of an art form, is it not? Take football. Football has a coach, and the coach is the artist of the team. He designs plays, right? He finds weaknesses in the opposing team and exploits them, right? So he makes up a creative play exploiting that weakness. Sports are an art form. So tell me again that art is not as important as sports. Tell me how these sports were created and tell me it wasn’t through art. Tell me how our very future does not depend HEAVILY on the arts.
Let me add something else to this. The military uses art. We are ENCOURAGED to perform art. I was in the RANGERS and art was HIGHLY ENCOURAGED. Do you know what we did? We did Theatersports. That’s right, we did improv. Special Forces does it as well. That is the other part of keeping mentally tough. To keep your mind from being so focused on a single objective that you miss what is going on everywhere around you. We played Mad Libs. We took Mad Libs seriously for its surrealism. Artists are creaters, Billings. Your god is an artist. So, I encourage you to bring to me something that wasn’t created by artists.
Expand your mind, Billings, you may find yourself far more capable than you think. You are already an artist, the way you can spin words and misinformation. Try and use that talent to do some good in the world, instead of contributing to the hate and intolerance that is already present. You just may regain some of that long lost credibility. Stay away from the Victorianist, single-minded, religious conformity, and you won’t be grouped in the same categories as Fred Phelps, the Klu Klux Klan, Nazi’s and your other hate groups. Let go. Be yourself, not who your parents beat you into. If you like men, then so be it. The only people who will ostracize you for it are others out there like yourself, and really, who needs people like that?
Praise or Condemn:
4
1
Nice try, my little friend, but I do not own an iPhone, nor do I ever aspire to.
Furthermore, the accusation that I am a secret homosexual is unfounded and slanderous. It is a common refrain for you liberals to attack someone with this claim. The ironic thing is that when you call me a homo, you’re using it as an insult. Then you people turn around and try to get all they special gay rights into law and want everyone sing Kumbaya and kissing homosexuals… So what is it? Do you love the gays are is being gay an insult to you? Make up your mind, won’t you please Mr. Hyporcrite?
As for sports, my journalism speaks for itself. Numerous scientific studies and family experiences have proven beyond a doubt that athletics is central to a young man developing properly. Team partnering teaches real life adult management tactics. The physical exercise fights away obesity and is great for the circulation. It also helps you take pride in your self, to learn that you’re becoming a man.
Art has been known to contribute to culture, but I think that whole argument is overstated. What would this world be without art? Pretty much the same in my book. Maybe a little less on tv. But my house and my car would look just the same. Not everything is art, mind you, building things we use is called engineering and sometimes pictures are just photographs, not “Art”.
You sound a tad pretentious I must say. Probably explains why you are so convinced that my faith is meaningless. Do you worry for your eternal soul, the uncomprimising end that we all must face when we are judged for our lives? Do you not shudder to think how St. Peter will look down upon you? I pray there is time for light in your life.
Welcoming Jesus into my days was the greatest moment in my life!
Praise or Condemn:
1
3
I have no opinion of gays. To me, they are just other people. I am not in position to judge a persons sexual orientation. That is it. A person is a person, nothing more. I am not a liberal, either, nor am I conservative. I don’t understand your “Mr. Hypocrite” reference.
I do not deny the importance of athletics. Not in the least, I believe everyone can use more exercise. It was your idiotic remark on the arts that I found baseless. You wouldn’t have cars with art, that is really the point. Art is often the connection of two unrelated ideas. The iPhone was a metaphor.
Your journalism is terrible. It sounds like a tabloid and you don’t do research. It does speak for yourself. Notice the amount of comments you recieved since someone posted an article of Fark.com? Notice how they are almost entirely negative? Would you say that is a proper reflection of your journalism? If I took this article to any university or credible news source and cited it as a factual reference I would be laughed out building. That is your journalism speaking for itself. Is that the legacy you wish to leave behind? You aren’t balanced enough to be taken seriously, yet not extreme enough to attain Fred Phelps’ status.
If I sound a tad pretentious, perhaps I am so. Pretentiousness, however, has little to do with this though. Your faith is not meaningless, it is shallow. You want to blame minorities and gays for your problems. You are spreading hate. That is not an act of faith. If it is, I want no part of it. Better to spend the eternity in hell with Lucifer than an in heaven with an intolerant god.
And speaking of which, my soul was lost when I was sent overseas to kill Muslim extremists. You know, the “conservative agenda.” Damned if I do, and damned if I don’t. I do not shudder at St. Peter. I will not shudder at any god. I will stand tall and face whatever crimes I may have committed. I am but one man, as they say. I just hope I don’t spend an eternity with the contributors of this site.
This is a battle you cannot win. The harder you fight, the more you will lose. Christianity is falling apart. Nobody buys this poor bill of goods. Society is phasing you out, just like bellbottoms. The Christian god will end up in the same place as Zeus and his brothers. Might as well face it. The church has done too much irrepairable harm. So, are you going to go down with the sinking ship and drown with the rats? Your buddy, Mr. Phelps is no doubt going to stay on that ship. Then again, he has little credibility as well, doesn’t he? His church is considered a hate group. He has money, though. Lots of money. Do you have that kind of money?
Speaking of which, is YOUR church a hate group yet? Is this what is taught in your church? If so then I wonder how long it will be when your church loses its tax exempt status. Times are changing, Mr. Billings. What are you going to do?
Praise or Condemn:
3
0
“So what is it? Do you love the gays are is being gay an insult to you?”
Homosexuality is not an insult to us, but we know that it’s an insult to YOU, which is why we use it against you.
“Numerous scientific studies and family experiences have proven beyond a doubt that athletics is central to a young man developing properly.”
Uh-huh, and what about young women?
“Team partnering teaches real life adult management tactics.”
It also teaches aggression and hostility. There’s nothing fun about being forced to play baseball in gym class and having to endure the vicious screams of your classmates when you do something wrong.
“The physical exercise fights away obesity and is great for the circulation.”
Clearly it didn’t work for you, then.
“It also helps you take pride in your self, to learn that you’re becoming a man.”
And what about becoming a woman?
“Not everything is art, mind you, building things we use is called engineering and sometimes pictures are just photographs, not “Art”.”
Yeah, and not everything is sports, either.
Praise or Condemn:
2
0
Well put, Claire. That is something I did fail to mention. Sports is most certainly NOT for everyone. It certainly wasn’t for me. And yet, I succeeded in the military, more so than some of those that did play competitive sports. I still believe it is important, however, for those it is important for. People who love to play sports, should play sports. Those who don’t, shouldn’t. Do what you love to do.
I do believe that everyone should maintain a healthy body, but sports is not the only way to do it. Sports is also not the only way to compete, either. As you put it, Claire, sports is not everything.
Praise or Condemn:
2
0
And another thing, and this is a tabloid/Oprah thing to do, studies don’t
“prove” anything. Any self-respecting scientist performing a study will NEVER, at the cost of his credibility as a scientist, say that his study PROVES something. Never. Studies suggest results. The only thing that can PROVE something is by experiment. That is it. This is because of the “Third Variable Problem.” This is why you will never be taken seriously as a journalist.
Praise or Condemn:
2
1
Wow, this is outrageous. Glee can certainly be looked at as “out there” when compared to other mainstream shows (but many cable shows such as “Dexter”, “Weeds” and “The L Word” make “Glee” look like a Sunday morning church sermon.) And, “out there” or not, any show is amenable to be criticized, and parents should definitely inform themselves of the contents of what their children and young teens watch.
That said, this “journalistic” piece did NOT do just that. You cannot condemn something because it goes against what you believe in– that is not journalism. Glee called Sarah Palin ‘stupid’? Well, it would have been just as bad to call her ‘smart.’ The criticism here should be to point out that Glee at times injects politically-loaded comments into its characters’ lines. That’s it. If parents are ok with that, let everyone watch Glee. If not, that’s their choice.
The same goes for the presence of homosexual characters, sexual behavior, teen pregnancy, divorce… These are all things that exist in the world, and that therefore can be invoked when creating television plots. Let parents and adults be their own judge. Shows should mostly be taken for their entertainment value, and whatever you don’t agree with can easily be brushed off. No one is going to change their values because a character on a show said so. Not even teens, if they are being raised in a good environment.
Now, all that garbage you wrote about characters’ weight gain, leathery skin, no Jews in Ohio, “ethnic” people, sports equaling virtue and rubbing against television sets is truly the work of an unintelligent, racist troglodyte (and that’s a generous euphemism.) You’re making conservatives and Christians look bad by pooling yourself in with them.
But I won’t stoop down to your level and nitpick at your ignorant rhetoric. I will say though, that your obsession with “sports” is senseless. What, a kid can either play football in high school or fail at life? You played football in high school, and now you’re a fat, bigoted excuse for a journalist. Yes, physical fitness is crucial, but can be achieved through many ways. Choir-singing kids can exercise regularly and go on to have non-musical careers. In Glee itself, in fact, the kids dance a lot, Rachel is shown as exercising daily, and several characters are ballet dancers. Moreover, physical fitness is not tied to physical appearance. You can be overweight and still fit– as the characters must be, if they can move around so quickly and frequently. The actors go on live tours, too, so their fitness carries on to their real life.
Another note is on Rachel’s singing. Lea Michele is a fantastic singer– just Google it. All of the cast lip-syncs, but to recordings of themselves made in a studio prior to shooting the scenes. Glee is entirely fictional, and aims to provide viewers with a high-quality musical and choreographic experience that could not be achieved impromptu. This is one of the show’s many quirks, and is not hidden from anybody. Neither does it take away from the fact that the cast is extremely talented.
Finally, I will say that, more than simply outrageous, your “arguments” are missed opportunities to really delve into an honest negative criticism of the show. You miss the point that it is meant to be exaggerated and borderline satirical. The plot lines don’t represent attempts to slowly mold a young teen’s fragile personality. On the contrary– the show constantly builds up stories only to deconstruct and even mock them the following week. The characters, similarly, are deeper than your shallow analysis. A true commentator– and a true journalist– would observe that. As for examples:
1) Sue Sylvester is not gay in the show. She is in fact homophobic at times. She is also a loving caregiver to her sister, who has Down syndrome. She puts up an angry and cold front, but it is clear that stems from being an underdog herself.
2) Mercedes is overweight, but clearly not unfit. A recent episode dealt with her issues with body image, relaying the positive message that starving yourself is detrimental to your health, and that people should be accepted as they are.
3) Will Schuester did not cheat on his wife with Emma. He had marital issues which he fought for, including a much welcomed pregnancy which turned out to be fake, at the fault of his wife. He simply let his feelings for Emma slowly surface, and did not so much as kiss her until after leaving his conniving wife. Recently he has engaged in more dubious sexual behavior, but at the same time, he is still a kind, altruistic person who gives his all to the Glee kids and handles Sue’s vicious attacks diplomatically. He surely has faults, but also virtues– just like anyone.
I will leave off here. I anticipate misguided comments to my post, as you’ve made to all the previous commenters. I can say, though, that I would be just as infuriated if I did not enjoy Glee, or if I were a Christian. I do happen to be a conservative from Ohio, where many of my high school classmates were Jewish, and some were even “ethnic,” oh my! That must be why I’m going to hell, don’t you think?
Please.
Praise or Condemn:
5
1
I don’t have the time to analyze each and every show on tv and I think your claim that it is okay compared to how worse other things are is simply outrageous. Is rape okay but genocide is so much worse? Your attempt at logic shows a unformed mind, unprincipled and unchallenged. I hope that you may mature to see life’s larger issues. God bless.
Praise or Condemn:
0
3
Mr. Billings,
I want to begin with stating that I can’t disagree with you more on most of your points; however, I do appreciate your writing this article. It provides for healthy debate and discussion. Articles such as yours definitely provide the controversy that you desire.
I was a bit confused by some of your assertions and wonder if we watched the same episode of Glee, by the way I am an adult not an ‘impressionable’ teen.
The show is simply the reflection of one of the many options available to our youth while in high school. There are team sports, art classes, drama clubs, glee clubs/choirs, bands, debate team and a host of other extra-curricular activities. In case you hadn’t noticed, the show is titled, ‘Glee’, not ‘Jocks’, ‘High School in America’ or some such name. The show’s focus is on the experience of kids in a glee club in Middle America.
I am not clear how you surmised that the character, Sue Sylvester, is a lesbian. As I recall she was in bed with a male principal and dated the male anchor in a previous episode. I haven’t seen a female date for Sue yet. Is she a lesbian merely because she doesn’t wear a dress, has shorter hair, is a strong woman, and is not of your political persuasion? Get over the former Governor of Alaska Palin comment. Have you ever heard some of the comments on Fox News or The Limbaugh Show in reference to ‘liberal’ politicians and persons? I suppose those are okay since they fit into your narrow definition of what it means to be an American, let alone a Christian in this country. By the way, here’s a news flash…although this country was founded by Christians predominantly, we are a nation of many faiths, which are protected and deserve the same respect which you ask for your brand of Christianity.
Madonna was not in the Glee episode. That was Jane Lynch aka Sue Sylvester or possibly a body double. The scene was about as homoerotic as watching paint dry. The dancers in the original and Glee remade video are all much older than either of Madonna’s sons (her biological or adopted son).
The episode or series doesn’t dismiss athletics or Christianity. It just reflects the diversity that exists in this country. Get over it, Mr. Billings. We are a nation of immigrants from Europe, Asia, Africa, South America, various Pacific, Atlantic and Caribbean Islands.
Your arbitrary and unkind comments about the actors’ appearance are both inaccurate and mean-spirited. I am not agreeing with you but if any of the actors gained weight, that is not a series condoning or dismissing the importance of athletics. We all know that the actors lip synch most if not all the numbers; however, most of the actors are accomplished Broadway performers. Your comments are dismissive and capricious. The Schuster and Pillsbury interactions are not condoning infidelity, because he has not cheated on his TV wife. The arbitrary and seemingly uninformed assessment of the season premiere of Glee is quite distasteful and disturbing.
America is not a monolithic society of Caucasian Christians. We are a diverse and vibrant country that holds our freedoms and rights in the highest of regard. I will defend to the death your right to an opinion, but I will also exercise mine to counter your limited scope of what it means to be a Christian in America or for that matter a good American
Praise or Condemn:
4
2
“The show is simply the reflection of one of the many options available to our youth while in high school…” Oh what garbage. When are you idiots going to understand that morality just doesn’t happen, it has to be taught and imposed if necessary. Children have to learn right from wrong and having sex and abortions strewn across our tv screens gives the worst life lessons possible. Your liberal “feel good” thinking is counterproductive and actually so faulty I don’t know where to begin. It’s people like you who let Lenin rise to power without anything but a wimper. Be well, comrade.
Praise or Condemn:
1
1
Have you ever thought that actions like that are shown alongside their consequences for a reason?
Praise or Condemn:
0
0
While there is so much wrong with this article, I will only point out one thing. It is clear you did not watch the episode’s you’re criticizing. Madonna did not guest star in this episode. That music video (which was actually just a reacreation of the original Vogue music video, a song made famous on it’s own, not by a movie) featured “Lesbian” Sue Sylvester. It was Kurt and Mercedes who put her in it to give her more self-confidence. Don’t pretend you know everything.
Congratulations on another article that proves you’re just writing to pass the time.
Helena
Praise or Condemn:
6
0
My little child:
“Have respect therefore to the prayer of thy servant, and to his supplication, o Lord my God, to hearken unto the cry and the prayer which thy servant prayeth before thee.” –2 Chronicles 6:19.
Praise or Condemn:
0
3
I am not a little child.
Unlike you, I’m not going to claim to know everything. I don’t completely understand that quote, but if it means what I am guessing, then all I have to say is this: I have no respect for lies or liars.
You do know that lying is a sin, right? And before you say that this is an opinion article, you are preaching facts that do not exist.
I am glad there are other people in the Christian community I can turn to for guidance. You, sir, are not one of them. The priests at my church speak the truth, the word of God. Your words, minus your irrelevant Bible quotes that you like to throw around to sound high and mighty over us meek mortals, are not God’s words.
Praise or Condemn:
1
0
“Sell everything you possess and give the money to the poor.” –Luke 18:22
Praise or Condemn:
0
0
Hey, I don’t really know you, but this article was highly offensive. If you are indeed a Christian, you would be more understanding of the natural differences between different people. I don’t know why you were always pointing out things one is born with, such as descent, skin color, sexual orientation, etc.; since when is it acceptable to judge people based on qualities they didn’t choose? This show is really harmless in the scope of society. The Palin thing was distasteful, but whatever. You could probably hear the same on many news programs. Lea Michele has an amazing voice, you cannot deny that. Cory Monteith has not gained any weight. There is nothing wrong with being a little bit chubby anyway. It is important to be happy the way you are. This show also provides good points, such as the episode “Home”, which inspired viewers to love themselves the way they are. It also is similar to a musical education class. This entire article is laughable. You are such a judgemental dick. Buddy, according to your beliefs, who makes the true judgement? Think about that.
The Arts are incredibly important. A home-run cannot move someone the way a beautiful song can. Sports are important for social and physical health, but Fine Arts help your mental, social, and emotional health. They are truly more important in the long run. You can play a piano at 80, but you can’t throw a 50 yard pass.
This entire site seems to be based on twisting the values of Christianity to point out peoples’ flaws. I’m agnostic, but I was raised in a Christian church all my life, so I know what I’m talking about. You need to understand that you can’t say all these awful things about people, and then back it up with “religion.” Bullshit. “Love thy neighbor as I have loved you.” Did you forget that? Your religion is based off of acceptance and forgiveness. You are a cold-hearted, monster of a person. You are hatred.
Praise or Condemn:
5
1
Glee is an accurate representation of American High Schools. I know that I was always fuckin’ and singin’.
Always.
Always.
Sometimes at the same time. But I might have been the only person doing it.
Praise or Condemn:
6
0
I would like to point something out that seems to have misunderstood.
Sorry to burst everyone’s bubble, but the music on the show is lip-synched, but the voices are the actors’ own. As is commonplace in movies and television shows which contain singing, the songs are recorded beforehand in a music studio to attain the best possible sound, and to accomodate for cutting between different camera angles and takes.
And I would also like to answer the point set forward in the last article about the singing abilities of the cast greatly exceeding those in a normal high school environment. This is entirely true. But would you tune in every week to watch a cast with warbly, off key singing voices? Of course not. That’s why good singers were cast.
Just trying to set the record straight.
Praise or Condemn:
5
0
Thank you for your lending your expertise to prove my point, although I disagree that the soundtracks are actually recorded by the actors themselves and not some entirely different paid performers or even from old albums.
Praise or Condemn:
0
4
They actually can sing. Look it up. Lea Michele (Rachel) and Matthew Morrison (Will) have been on Broadway.
Praise or Condemn:
3
0
Ummm, Enraged Commenting People, I’m pretty certain this whole commentary is what’s known as satire. See onion.com.
Praise or Condemn:
2
2
Great, another deep thinker with dialup. Save the conspiracy theories for your next ACORN meeting and stop trying to suppress my free speech.
“The steadfast love of the Lord never ceases, his mercies never come to an end; they are new every morning…” –Lamentations 3:22-23.
Praise or Condemn:
1
2
Why is it that only people who agree with you are allowed free speech? Why is it that you can say things that offend other people but the minute someone offends you, you attack them?
I don’t know how you can call yourself a christian.
Praise or Condemn:
3
0
“Sell everything you possess and give the money to the poor.” –Luke 18:22
aaaaaaand take a shot.
Praise or Condemn:
0
0
Dear Mr. Billings,
As a mother of three, I found you articles very helpful. I honestly didn’t know “Glee” contained such explict content! I feel ashamed that people would post comments like the ones they’ve been directing at you on a Christian website! As my eldest daughter, Marianne, is now fifteen, I would love to let her to watch “Glee”! Which episode would you say is the most sexually expict, and which is the least? Are there any messages I should specificly tell her not to follow? Bad role models? Please respond to me, I this is very important for the safety of my children mentally and sexually. If you wish not respond in the comments section, feel free to email me the answers to my questions and any more information you find helpful at: christydavidson20@yahoo.com.
Thank you in advance, Sir.
Sincerly,
Christina Davidson.
Praise or Condemn:
1
2
Stephenson Billings, you have just destroyed my faith in human kind.
Praise or Condemn:
2
0
Ignore everything I’ve said.
I’ve come to the conclusion that this is a joke.
Praise or Condemn:
2
1
I’d like to point out that singing is a big part of the church. Choir is another way to express your love and devotion towards Jesus Christ. So you’re implying that those who sing in your churches choir are anti-American and un-Christian? Really smart.
“He gyrates his pelvis in alluring ways as if begging the young men of America to rub up against their television screens in passion and sympathy.”
You do realize that by saying “alluring” you come off as rather homosexual yourself? Or bicurious, whichever you prefer. I know plenty of people who watch Glee all the time and have never been compelled to hump their televisions. You’re probably one of the very few who have actually considered that (which makes you sound even more in the closet).
But seriously, embrace your inner sexuality! Jesus loves everyone, no matter their sexuality, ethnicity, or religion. If you really were a Christian, you would understand that.
Praise or Condemn:
2
0
“Most parents seemed concerned that Glee was promoting homosexuality, atheism and careers in the arts while dismissing Christianity and traditional athletics.”
Wow, terrible parenting. Why don’t you pull your American flag and crucifix out of your “sin hole” or wodeva and listen. Homosexuality is perfectly natural and if it promotes heterosexuality why can’t it promote other sexualities? Do parents want their children to be emotionly blind and morally dilusioned?
There’s nothing wrong with atheism.
What if a child is physically disabled or not good at sports? I’m not good at sports but I have an imagination, I can draw and write and read and play the tenor horn and some stuff on the keyboard. I’m much more proud of those simple gifts each one of us has that jumping over a stick. I’d much prefer to go on a nice long walk in the countryside, looking at streams and grass and trees and wildlife than anything else. But I’m not saying athletics is bad, I mean I’m not bad at gymnastics, but you’ve got to give everything a go
Praise or Condemn:
3
2
wats up people, just wanted to say wats up for know nebie here.
Praise or Condemn:
3
0
Hello and welcome to our Christian community!!!!
Praise or Condemn:
2
0
I am a fervent Christian and also a Glee-lover. While the main premise of the show is a great one, I don’t agree with a lot of the values that they promote. I admire the fact that you’re trying to open peoples’ eyes about the negative sides of Glee (most of which people already know about, anyway), but you’re going about it ENTIRELY the wrong way.
For one, if you want people to listen to you, you should have your facts straight and only report what is correct.
Lea Michele (who plays Rachel) IS an amazing singer. She’s been on Broadway almost her entire life. For Glee, they prerecord all of their vocals instead of singing them during the camera sequences. Better sound quality, and it helps with the making of the CDs, I’m sure. All of her singing is her own voice; there are many people everywhere whose singing voices don’t match their speaking voices.
Have you ever heard that the camera adds ten pounds? Only immaculately thin or perfectly proportioned people will look perfect onscreen. And so what if someone gained a few pounds–isn’t that usually better than having an eating disorder or not having proper nutrition? As for how everyone looks–there has been no evidence of looking any more haggard than the normal person might under stress. Not even that, actually.
And, where you mention how “the character Sue sells her body to the school’s Hindu principal?” That is not what happened. From the beginning, we establish that Sue is insane and awful. Her ludicrous actions are part of why so many like her. But this is not what happens.
For one, Principal Figgins is a Christian. This fact isn’t largely elaborated, but it is shown when Figgins gets a list of approved songs from his minister for the Glee club–many of which are said to be about Jesus.
In the episode where he and Sue go to dinner, she drops something in his drink. He wakes up next to her, and she proceeds in telling him how the blackmail is going to work–starting with how she has to listen to him or she will tell his wife and the leader of his church.
And Madonna is never once in this show. That is Sue, played by Jane Lynch.
And also–never does Glee say that sports are unimportant. Glee just emphasizes how the arts programs are important, too–especially because they’re dying and more people are turning to sports.
I respect your values, because many of them are shared. I also respect that you’re trying to reach out to parts of America that don’t share these values. I don’t know anything more about you or this program that isn’t in this article, however, and what I do know isn’t all good.
You clearly have good intentions, but you’re not carrying them out effectively. You shouldn’t be insulting the people who comment on this, for one; it doesn’t help your cause. Take the high road.
Another thing that would help your cause amazingly would be getting your facts straight; there is very little in this article that is accurate.
I hope you’re praying for these people as much as you are attacking them–God can do way more than any number of people.
God bless you and help you
Praise or Condemn:
1
0
Wait, isn’t this site just satire? I really think these guys are joking… at least, that’s what a friend told me when he sent me this link. I thought the article was really funny by the way.
Praise or Condemn:
2
1
This article is fucking retarded. Why is it wrong that the show promotes homosexuality? Would you rather kids watch Fox News? Which promotes being a pompous, bible thumping, racist, bigot, ass wipe? Don’t answer that question, because I know your answer will be yes.
Furthermore, who cares if the characters have gained weight? Are they obese (like so many white, middle class followers of Christ) So what if they drink alcohol? Jesus drank, you ass hole. And don’t give me that ‘wine wasn’t as strong back then’ bull shit. Shut the fuck up and write about something that matters. Like about how much of a tool you are, or how you calling kid actors fat is sending a worse message than a harmless musical television show ever could. Somewhere in heaven, Jesus is weeping. Because it’s senseless, ignorant, idiotic, and down right FUCKING STUPID AS SHIT people like you that give Christians a bad name.
Oh, and by the way, WHY THE FUCK COULDN’T A JEW LIVE IN OHIO? YOU’RE SO STUPID MY BRAIN CAN’T EVEN COMPREHEND YOUR INCAPACITY TO LEARN.
PS – Go suck a fat dick, you ass hole.
Praise or Condemn:
3
2
I would much prefer my children watch Fox news, thank you.
Praise or Condemn:
0
3
I’d comment on this, but you admit to watching a bunch of dirty, ill-informed liars babble about shit, and that says enough already.
Praise or Condemn:
1
1
If you ask me, it’s people like you who are going to hell. Why poison your children’s minds by making them watch homophobic, fat, old white men that cheat on their wives give incomplete, biased news?
Oh, that’s right. Because you’re a homophobic, fat, old white man. My mistake.
Praise or Condemn:
1
1
Oh, and didn’t I tell you not to answer my question about Fox News? Why not address one of my other very valid points instead of reiterating you’re inability to listen to others, and to function at a brain capacity higher than .05%.
Praise or Condemn:
1
1
First of all, saying that the arts are not as important as sports really, really bothers me. The arts are key in education, much more so than sports. They transcend all barriers and involve the mind, body, and soul to create outlets for creativity that develop very important thinking and life skills !! I could go on and on and on!!!
Also……
Glee has great messages about ACCEPTING different people- something you clearly do not grasp.
Lea Michele is a phenomenal singer. Don’t believe me? -http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rngAIY-0ZoI
Glee is NOT a “children’s show”.
Finn is NOT fat. Where the heck did you get that???
What are you even talking about when you ask why is there a Jewish girl in Ohio?? There are Jews all over.
You, as a racist, assumed Principal Figgins was Hindu. He’s a Christian.
And this,
” He gyrates his pelvis in alluring ways as if begging the young men of America to rub up against their television screens in passion and sympathy. But all that promise comes to naught. The scene climaxes abruptly, adding absolutely nothing to the plot of the show.”
Really??? Just, really????????? Wow….
You, dear sir, are the opposite of any Christian I know.
This is why atheists think all of us are idiots.
Praise or Condemn:
3
0
omg… are you serious??? its a good show. you say its bad… IT HAS AN ABSITINANCE CLUB!!! and the comments you made on the character of sue… the character is not gay. the actress is, but the character is not. as hard as this for you to understand, not all homozexuals are cliches or stereotypes. i myself am gay, and im not butch, im just a normal teenage girl. if anything, glee helps us see the consequences of certain actions. for instance, take the quinn storyline. she had sex without contraception, and she ended up pregnant. if anything, this is promoting safe sex, and this is a good thing. now, i know you are going to try and contradict everything i have said in this comment (the key word being try) so go ahead, do your worst, bring it on. it wont be anything i havnt heard before from bible bashers trying to stuff religion down my atheist (thats right atheist) throat. ok… rant over
Praise or Condemn:
1
0
Well this was interesting to read. My whole family, a family of Christians, love this show. It deals with real problems in high school. Teen pregnancy, ridicule, and homosexuality are all in high school. As for Lea Michele, Rachel Berry the “Jewish Girl”, Does not lip sync. She’s been on Broadway since she was 8 and she has sung live many times. Her voice is amazing and real. Chris Colfer, Kurt, did not shake his hips in a sexual way during Vogue. Ever. Cory Monteith, Finn, did not gain weight either. He’s actually lost weight. As for his clumsiness while dancing, that’s the point. In the show, he isn’t very good at dancing. And Will Schuester never cheated on his wife with Emma. Sure, they showed interest in each other as possible foreshadowing. He never once had any sexual relations with her until after he and his wife separated in episode 12. I have a feeling you didn’t really watch the show because you called Sue Sylvester the football coach when in fact, she is the Cheerleading coach. The football coach is Ken Tanaka. If you did watch the show, you only took from it what you wanted. And for the record, Quinn Fabray is a Christian in the show.
Praise or Condemn:
0
0
hmmm, pretty sure cory lost weight over the break between season 1 and 2. also, glee isn’t just for children. its for a wide audience therefore i feel like their pop culture references are not sending subliminal messages to children. its on at 8 or 9 at night so young children shouldn’t be watching it anyways… this show in no ways says the arts are more important than athletics but encourages people to participate in BOTH. also, last i heard religion is not based on location; jews could be anywhere. madonna isn’t just for homosexuals; she is such a versatile performer and appeals to a lot of different people. you made the vogue video seem much more graphic than it was. vogue also was not made famous by the devil wears prada (thats actually RUNWAY magazine). also lea michele (as much as i dislike her in real life) has a GREAT voice. she is real, never lip synched. she started on broadway at age 8 in les miz so i doubt she is “lacking ability” in the singing department. glee offers a wide variety of different high school experiences; thats the way high schools are these days. if you don’t approve of teens then you should try reaching out to them and not causing such slander on the internet about glee.
all in all i think this article is absurd. you need to get a grip
PS. you are a horrible representation of a christian as well as a journalist
Praise or Condemn:
2
0
Sue Sylvester is not a lesbian. Jane Lynch is, but not Sue.
Get the facts right.
So what if there’s a lot of homosexuality on the show, there’s nothing wrong with it.
Praise or Condemn:
3
0
[...] giving some of that love back to the world. Oxfam is a good organization. Thao is a good musician. Glee is a good [...]
Praise or Condemn:
0
0
“The homosexual character Kurt appears, flaunting his naked body and batting his eyelashes in a sexual frenzy. He gyrates his pelvis in alluring ways as if begging the young men of America to rub up against their television screens in passion and sympathy”
HAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHA whaaattt?
That actually made me crack up
Bahahahha, ‘flaunting his naked body and batting his eyelashes in a sexual frenzy’, hahahahahah aaah good one….
Praise or Condemn:
1
0
I honestly don’t know what’s wrong with art. I’m a natural born artist, and at high school the creativity really helps. Now concerning Glee, sure, I agree that the show can be a bit risqué and at times a bit too inappropriate for children, but honestly, it’s not a children’s show. It’s ment for young adults who can understand and empathize the underlying theme of Glee, which to express yourself and love who you are, no matter your race, ethnicity, religion, or sexuality. Sure, there are like FOUR gays on the show, but does it really promote homosexuality? Plus, might I point, Billings, that though athleticism is a good thing, so is the ability to express oneself through artistic ability. Art is art. Sure, some artists are dirt poor and unemployed bums. But what about those cinematic geniuses, those ‘artists’, as you will, that take a beautiful story, and make it into an experience. Or those musical talents that make music that inspire. There’s a bit of art in everything, from painting, to music, to acting, even a piece of technology. Don’t you think it took enginuity and innovation one finds in artists to craft some of the everyday things you find today? All I’m saying is, sure, sports build character. But arts help develop a mind that can think beyond the horizon and think up ideas no other can.
P.S. What’s wrong with Jews? Wasn’t Jesus one?
Praise or Condemn:
1
0
Art is worthless without patriotism and sobriety.
Praise or Condemn:
0
2
Uncultured swine.
Praise or Condemn:
0
0