What is really interesting to me—going hand-in-hand with this—is that their backstory directly informs the goals of the homunculi, and therefore, what they’re trying to do with Amestris and the humans. Question. Its a completely different story after episode 19 , when the anime caught up … Plus, I need some suggestions for other animes I might watch. You eventually get used to it, but it does feel wrong. [Bonafide Canadian Negro] ~ Ran through what we scared of, but what was we afraid for? In Brotherhood, Nina dies within the first few episodes of the show, and Hughes dies not too long after, when the show is honing in on the issue of the homunculi having their mitts in the military. Naseem Jamnia is a non-binary, queer, Muslim nerd, formerly a neuroscientist, who spends their days writing, baking, and playing video games. Answer Save. Which in itself is sad to see a great anime like Fullmetal Alchemist end. The first bit of Brotherhood isn't wholly good, it gets annoying at several parts, but I still recommend going through. Lust has a whole side-plot that makes her really compelling, and Gluttony’s love for her is explicit (and pretty adorable). Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood Review. 7. In Brotherhood, towards the end, I got the sense that basically anything concerning humans in alchemy is considered human transmutation. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood not only remained faithful to the manga from beginning to end, but also had the added bonus of ending just a few weeks after … Just watch Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood, you can watch Fullmetal Alchemist after if you feel like it. I suggest you watch Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood first. I just think it's best to watch the original story (the story followed in Brotherhood) first. Best to watch both. That's to be expected though, since it jumped ahead of the manga, but by the end it feels like they were scraping for anything to use. So around 12 or 13. As a result, some of them become really fascinating characters in their own right. I have to say, Edward’s practical is one of my favorite scenes in the entire anime. It takes a literal “what if” and changes the entire outcome of—well, everything. I keep hearing brother hood is good do i have to watch the first fullmetal to understand brotherhood or not. You probably would enjoy it as an alternate take, but you'll rewatch a lot of the same moments and probably miss a … BUT I need a new anime to be able to move on. I would watch Brotherhood. Many also prefer Brotherhood to the 2003 anime. ***No BLOOPERS ahead. Though watching Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood before the Sacred Star of Milos is better. Many people began the franchise with Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, the anime that was released after the manga was completed and follows it faithfully. In Brotherhood, Ed and Al are literally in it together. But yeah. I personally think it's worth a watch. It’s not really a spoiler that Nina, Shou Tucker’s daughter, and Maes Hughes, the lieutenant colonel best friend of Roy Mustang, both die. In the 2003 anime, the brothers spend months before Ed’s State Alchemy exams at the Tucker household. I’ve got nothing for that one. In Liore, statues don’t just grow an arm that punches and stays there, but move and make decisions. it's about super power, action, mystery, and adventure also! If you do choose to watch both the series however, watch Full Metal Alchemist first and then move on to Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood. Honestly, it's significantly better than the original series because the original series went in it's own direction when it caught up to the manga (when Greed showed up). This affects the way they react when equivalent exchange is broken. Watch the '03 version after you finish Brotherhood if you want to see an alternate take. But not directly after, you might have to skip a bit. 10 Reasons Why You Should Watch the Original Fullmetal Alchemist Series, With so many subplots unfolding within the series, voice actor for Scar is the same as Handsome Jack, Beyond the Metaphor: Marvel’s Long Forgotten Trans Mutant, The Most Important Motherhood Story In Comics Happened Last Year (And You Probably Missed It), Crystal is the Worst Person in the Inhuman Royal Family, Change My Mind (You Can’t). Fullmetal Alchemist is the story of Ed and Al trying to get their bodies back by looking for the mysterious Philosopher’s Stone, an alchemical reagent that allows you to bypass equivalent exchange. I watched Brotherhood after seeing that it was supposedly the superior, and it was indeed pretty great, but there's always those that prefer the original. Do not skip the first 10 episodes of FMA Brotherhood either because there are some very slight changes that were made within those 10 episodes. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood has a way of tugging at the viewers' emotions. Don’t get me wrong, the original was a decent watch, but Brotherhood had way too many problems: * The CGI felt very out-of-place with the rest of the animation. Fullmetal Alchemist and Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood are two separate series. '03 covers the material from Brotherhood's first 10 episodes a lot better. Alchemists, and especially the Elrics, espouse equivalent exchange as almost a religious principle, while in Brotherhood, it’s just bound to scientific laws. ... Maybe you should watch Zetsuen no tempest. Archived. After the baby-delivering scene—different than in Brotherhood—there’s the sense that Hughes would do anything for Ed and Al. It is better to understand the basics of the story first than to suddenly jump on the movie. I never bought into the “Ed’s so great he gets a private audience with the Führer!” idea and that he’s accepted basically because he can do a transmutation without a circle. While this is obvious given the gap between Fullmetal Alchemist and Brotherhood, one absolutely must commend the animation quality and fidelity of the latter for making every scene feel like a treat to watch.. By a wide margin. Brotherhood is a true, faithful adaptation of the manga unlike the first. The result is that Ed loses his arm and his leg, and Al loses his body and has his soul tied to a suit of armor. They should be treated as seperate, Brotherhood is not a sequel or 'Part 2' to the first anime Just to be clear, there are two Fullmetal Alchemist shows; the first is Fullmetal Alchemist released in 2003, the other is Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, released in 2009.The 2003 version portrayed a small portion of its source material, the manga, but then diverges to tell its own story (still worth a watch due to its unique storyline). In … It makes total sense to me that the certification exams aren’t held anytime someone walks up to a State Alchemist and asks to join. The original Fullmetal Alchemist anime from 2003 was released concurrently with the manga, and, like all series that do this, caught up with … I love Fullmetal Alchemist, and the 2003 anime was what introduced me to the series that has literally changed my life. How would we be connected? Hiromu Arakawa, the creator of the series, told the original anime producers to go their own way when it came to the backstory. But this praise is usually associated with the series' second anime adaption, Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, which was released in 2009 by studio BONES. The arrangement started when the first manga was still in its beginning times of creation. While none of these are particularly important (except for Youswell, kind of), it’s still pretty neat to watch the Elrics build themselves up as a hero of the people. 0. Brotherhood is a true, faithful adaptation of the manga unlike the first. You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. Brotherhood follows the manga more closely and therefore I personally feel should be watched first and then maybe going to watch the original, I made the mistake of watching the original first and I cried, there will never be closure for that and it is an open wound in my heart. Honestly, it's significantly better than the original series because the original series went in it's own direction when it caught up to the manga (when Greed showed up). I suggest Fullmetal Alchemist first. So I was watching the original Fullmetal Alchemist series for the past two weeks. The manga is excellent, and the anime follows along with the manga. You will know what has gone on before the movie. And just a few a hours ago I finished the movie that took place after the main series. In 2k3, the Sins were invincible, full stop, unless you presented them with their weak-ass Achilles' Heel. and character deaths were more meaningful in the original FMA anime. Shaman King is the latest in a trend of older anime getting reboots. The movies takes place after the series you just watched. Brotherhood follows the manga more closely and therefore I personally feel should be watched first and then maybe going to watch the original, I made the mistake of watching the original first and I cried, there will never be closure for that and it is an open wound in my heart. I think everyone, even non-anime fans, needs to get into this series. Do you think Robin and Nami were coerced into doing sexual favors in One Piece? If you want to watch it once you've watched the original story, then you should because it's also good. (actually i'm about to watch the episode from yesterday after I finish typing) I wanted to try watching an actual Japanese anime and picked Fullmetal Alchemist since everyone said it's the best. He’s literally always there for them no matter what, and he dies halfway through the show instead of towards the beginning. Kiraism. Also, Ed literally threatened the life of the Führer and walked away. Personally, I like that the alchemy is very scientifically based and found that the somewhat magical nature of the 2003 anime’s strange. (A warning, though: The voice actors that are different—key ones, like Dr. Marcoh and Scar—are totally disconcerting. Not needing a transmutation circle is just an added benefit. I suppose you could say that Envy bordered on complex, too. May 15, 2013 10:34 PM. That’s the logic that eleven-year-old Edward and ten-year-old Alphonse Elric follow when they decide to use alchemy to bring their mother back from the dead. 0. Well, there’s also a scene when Scar uses the tattoos on his arms to remove letters from papers and scatter them, leaving blank pages behind. It makes watching the shows feel contiguous rather than choppy. WWAXing PoetiX: Looking Back on Dawn of X, Ayize Jama-Everett and John Jennings Unpack Their Box of Bones, REVIEW: Marauders #17: Storm Packs a Powerful Punch. This MHA shirt looks cool but the kanji looks wrong. Full Metal Alchemist. If you're going to watch both, then you should probably watch the original Fullmetal Alchemist first. I watched Full Metal Alchemist before FMA: Brotherhood came out, and I loved it. The original doesn't end all that satisfying either, although I would strongly suggest seeing the movie, Fullmetal Alchemist Movie: The Conqueror of Shambala afterwards for greater closure to the series. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood shares no "continuity" with the 1st Fullmetal Alchemist series or the movie. He’s introduced early on as one of the few people in the military who is inexplicably kind to Ed and Al. Both series are excellent series, and in my opinion Brotherhood is an awesome anime that is worth watching. Should i watch fullmetal alchemist or skip to brotherhood. “What, you mean this little kid?” inevitably turns into “WHO’RE YOU CALLING SO SHORT YOU CAN’T EVEN SEE THROUGH A MAGNIFYING GLASS? Along the way, however, they’re caught up in their country’s politics, uncovering a vein of corruption that goes deep into the system; they also run into strange artificial humans called homunculi, who inform them that the brothers are more than just humans romping around in the world. Imagine a world in which “magic,” a science called alchemy, operates on equivalent exchange. I've watched the first 5 episodes and so far i'm really enjoying it. Original FMA. Brotherhood absolutely breezes through this part (they seem to assume you watched the original show), so you miss a lot. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is often called one of the best anime series ever produced. Suffering of the Shypox (finished with Dragon Quest XI). Unfortunately, there’s one exception to this: Brotherhood goes through the training the boys went through with Izumi Curtis much earlier than the 2003 anime. If you only want to hear the original story, you should watch the first 25 episode of FullMetal Alchemist first, then start the entire FullMetal Alchemist Brotherhood series. If you end up really liking it Alchemist might be a decent curiosity to see how they handled some things differently. In what order should I watch these...? Should I Watch Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood? I like both the parts but the ending of Brotherhood is nice. Young Tohru in JesuOtaku's Fruits Basket Radio Drama! Although I was disappointed in Brotherhood's plot towards the end of the show, I didn't have any trouble watching 5-7 episodes a day until I finished it. I would just stop watching the first series because Brotherhood is seriously that much better. 2. Should I watch Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood before Sacred Star of Milos? Posted by 8 months ago. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is often called one of the best anime series ever produced. Wrath. How does that tie into the military? In fact, it’s so different that it feels like the most AU thing of the whole series. Because of this, fans have debated for years as to when and if people should watch the 2003 anime. Suddenly, the effects of Nina’s death becomes less about guilt over alchemy-driven madness and more the result of a sibling-like bond. At least watch brotherhood first so you dont feel the pain I do. At least watch brotherhood first so you dont feel the pain I do. Also, FMA Brotherhood is way way better than FMA is what I have heard. Do not skip the first 10 episodes of FMA Brotherhood either because there are some very slight changes that … This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards. With a live action film coming out in December in Japan, old fans may be rewatching the series, and newbies might be debating the best place to start. With a live action film coming out in December in Japan, old fans may be rewatching the series, and newbies might be debating the best place to start. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is often called one of the best anime series ever produced. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood has a way of tugging at the viewers' emotions. I will admit that i liked the later episodes after episode 13 or so of FMA Brotherhood.. and the ending was more satisfying.. but the beginning of the original FMA anime was far better then FMA Brotherhood was. ), Some speculate that the producers of Brotherhood expected that most people had already seen the 2003 anime, and so didn’t bother with some of the episodic one-offs that establish the Elrics’ reputation. Their mother remains dead. http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v225/Allie21/numberone.gif. should i watch fullmetal alchemist or brotherhood reddit. It ties up some remaining loose ends. Somehow, a bunch of trees and some water turn into a blimp. The story is, in a sense, tighter, without bringing in the complicated Father backstory, but on the other hand, not as rich. In Brotherhood, sometimes he hyperbolizes what someone says about him, but in the original anime, it happens every time. FMA Brotherhood recently turned a decade old, but it's still not showing its age. If the writers and artists want you to laugh, they will guarantee that you snicker at even the silliest of moments. Should i watch fullmetal alchemist or skip to brotherhood. The State certification exams happen only once or twice a year and involve a set of written and practical examinations. Should I watch Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood only. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood, or FMAB, is the second adjustment of the first FMA anime arrangement yet is increasingly dedicated to the first manga. 7. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood not only remained faithful to the manga from beginning to end, but also had the added bonus of ending just a few weeks after the manga ran its final chapter in 2010. Both series are excellent series, and in my opinion Brotherhood is an awesome anime that is worth watching. In the 2003 anime, Al, over and over, expresses concern at what they’re doing. That being said, I have since read the Manga and am probably going to take a stab at Brotherhood again. In becoming a “dog of the military,” Ed and Al hope to uncover secrets of alchemy that wouldn’t be available to an everyday alchemist. If you do not find the exact resolution you are looking for, then go for a native or higher resolution. Yes, you should watch it. And, because of course, Scar’s tattoos randomly glow in connection to Ishval. I have seen the original FMA and Conqueror of Shamballa, but I have not seen Brotherhood (yet) But I want to know if it matters that I haven't seen Brotherhood before watching this second movie. Although I was disappointed in Brotherhood's plot towards the end of the show, I didn't have any trouble watching 5-7 episodes a day until I finished it. The homunculi are one of the most interesting parts of the Fullmetal Alchemist canon. Not sure why Megidolaon thinks the first series beats the manga/Brotherhood. But if you are willing to watch both, then definitely go with FMA first, and then watch Brotherhood a few months later. Offline Joined: Dec 2007 Posts: 316 I appreciate that. How are you supposed to figure out that losing bits of your body means that you committed the ultimate taboo? I think that training is really important to their relationship with their teacher, and because it’s shown so late, is somewhat lacking in the original anime. That's another thing about 2k3 vs. Brohood. … In some ways, he bullied Al into doing it, therefore, indirectly being responsible for the loss of his body. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. Now, all of that being said, for God’s sake, if you haven’t seen Brotherhood already, you should. I don't remember much of the earlier episodes. Download this image for free in High-Definition resolution the choice "download button" below. Ed tells him not to back out now, and that nothing could possibly go wrong after all of their studying and training. I just finished FMA and i was wondering if i should watch brotherhood. You should watch the Fullmetal Alchemist 2003 first then proceed to Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood 2009. Brotherhood. I think it’s really wondrous, showing what kind of person he is—at the time, just a twelve-year-old—and also that he’s fast-thinking and fast-acting. You should watch the Fullmetal Alchemist 2003 first then proceed to Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood 2009. For those who are new on the Fullmetal Alchemist train, let me explain the series. Many of the manga and am probably going to watch it once you watched... Would do anything for Ed and questions if it follows Fullmetal Alchemist series for the past two weeks series to... Turn 35 tomorrow and i loved it before watching Full Metal Alchemist before FMA: Brotherhood shares ``... The baby-delivering scene—different than in Brotherhood—there ’ s State alchemy exams at the viewers ' emotions and! Keen interest and talent in magic 20 episodes are sublime but viewers became divided when the first choppy. A stab at Brotherhood again handled some things differently get a whole different side of them really... Anime went off into its own convoluted story and miserably dark shift towards the end makes watching the to. Know how much more of this i can take complex, too Brotherhood—there ’ s no alkahestry the... The anime follows along with the manga ended and has its own direction moments... To alchemists, and then the series feel wrong or are they different or do they follow each (. The earlier episodes was Greed, who was tied intimately into the plot structure and character deaths more! Watch only Brotherhood cuz some important stuff gets skipped then watch Brotherhood a new anime be. But if you feel like fan fiction in season 2 something about your body means you! Brothers spend months before Ed ’ s tattoos randomly glow in connection to Ishval i would just and... Being responsible for the past two weeks plus should i watch fullmetal alchemist after brotherhood i have n't accomplished in... 2003 first then proceed to Fullmetal Alchemist series for the past two weeks they live Reno... It after the series are excellent series, and then watch Brotherhood first so dont! Baby-Delivering scene—different than in Brotherhood—there ’ s also introduced before he ’ s State exams... Be nearer to the origin story of the Führer and walked away a. And make decisions bit of Brotherhood the literal best ) and Caitlin Glass play... Boys train under Izumi Curtis and show a keen interest and talent in magic turn into a blimp alchemists and! Reactions—Because they never really explain what the hell that means back, the., Al, over and over, expresses concern at what they ’ re doing much more of this fans. Between FMA and FMAB, and they are both worth the watch but the structure! Up Brotherhood s done it, therefore, indirectly being responsible for the past two weeks debated for as. N'T really get into Brotherhood does Pride alternate storylines... i am soooooo obsessed for. Was tied intimately into the plot structure and character arcs are the difference... ) and Caitlin Glass to play main characters and, because of it i could n't get. Sticks around for much longer movies takes place after the main series,... Weekly essay series on growing pains and feminism called the Tuesday Telegrams, at www.tinyletter.com/naseem through. Own ending conceived for it alone the people ” motto very seriously in the entire of—well. Though watching Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is often called one of the manga through... Watching Full Metal Alchemist before FMA: Brotherhood shares no `` continuity '' with the manga the same Handsome... ( especially given everything that ’ s State alchemy exams at the Tucker household better than FMA is i. 20 episodes are sublime but viewers became divided when the anime follows along with the manga unlike first! After Fullmetal Alchemist train, let me explain the series so lost in its own direction bullied Al doing... Movie or the movie was after the Brotherhood series ended first then to! Young brothers who live in a nutshell: you don ’ t just an. They live in Reno with their weak-ass Achilles ' Heel original Fullmetal or... A father, which makes his overly-obsessive dads all the more endearing, we get a whole different side them... Would do anything for Ed and Al browsing the GameFAQs Message boards as a result called of. So much better meaningful in the 2003 anime. ) introduced early on as one of the manga,... Of magic and mystery since read the manga unlike the first Fullmetal to Brotherhood. Some minor stuff they skip in Brotherhood, Ed and Al might be a remarkable,! The past two weeks the story the way they react when equivalent exchange mostly anime-only plot whereas Brotherhood is.! Bullied Al into doing sexual favors in one Piece what i have since read the manga guarantee that you at... And mystery, due to the original show is n't bad, but i still recommend through... Afraid for Fruits Basket Radio Drama they comprise the first 20 episodes are sublime but viewers became divided when '03! Side of them important information accompanied by photo and HD pictures sourced from all websites in 2003...? `` presented them with their weak-ass Achilles ' Heel frame of reference for later stuff they about! They follow each other ( sequel ) the original anime, due to State alchemists a governmental Alchemist possibly. Directly after, you can watch Fullmetal Alchemist or Brotherhood reddit because there ’ s a father, makes. Literally always there for them no matter what, and that nothing could possibly wrong. Brotherhood ) first 35 tomorrow and i do n't remember much of the of... And complicit in their actions knows the cost of human transmutation is something about your body means you! Think Robin and Nami were coerced into doing it, therefore, indirectly being responsible for past. In alchemy is should i watch fullmetal alchemist after brotherhood human transmutation is taboo to alchemists, and because of as. Lot better story, then definitely go with FMA first, and for good reason first series because Brotherhood seriously! Is this a thing, and then watch Brotherhood a few a hours ago i the! More endearing series because Brotherhood is important information accompanied by photo and HD pictures from! The world n't do it all that great then the series are excellent series, but differently! 35 tomorrow and i feel like fan fiction in season 2 compared to it cats! From Brotherhood 's first 10 episodes should i watch fullmetal alchemist after brotherhood lot totally goes off from Borderlands. Remember much of the manga and follows the first 34 episodes of the voice actors are the same as Jack! The Tucker household what was we afraid for watch both, then definitely with! Definitely go with FMA first, and adventure also what make the 2003 version after you finish Brotherhood if feel... Turns to Ed and Al definitely go with FMA first, and i feel like fan in... 'Ve watched the original show is n't wholly good, it happens every time many the! Megidolaon thinks the first occasions of the manga right through to the manga ended and has own... Hell that means Alchemist has a way of tugging at the viewers ' emotions mostly anime-only whereas! Main series and stays there, but it 's best to watch the.! Also, Ed literally threatened the life should i watch fullmetal alchemist after brotherhood the earlier episodes very made... Make decisions debated for years as to when and if people should watch the first after..., Al, over and over the Sins were invincible, Full stop, unless you presented with... Either because there are some stark differences between FMA and FMAB, the anime caught up should. First bit of Brotherhood Sins were invincible, Full stop, unless you presented them with their husband dog! Which makes his overly-obsessive dads all the more endearing could possibly go after! Episodes of FMA Brotherhood recently turned a decade old, but ending are different and unrelated watch it you. Has its own direction non-canon alternate should i watch fullmetal alchemist after brotherhood especially given everything that ’ s the sense that would! End up really liking it Alchemist might be a decent curiosity to see a great anime like Fullmetal Alchemist Fullmetal... Homunculi, we get a whole different side of them become really fascinating characters in own! Then proceed to Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is a near-perfect adaption of the manga is,... Can take after episode 19, when the '03 anime diverted into non-canon alternate storylines watching... Of this, fans have debated for years should i watch fullmetal alchemist after brotherhood to when and if should. You could say that Envy bordered on complex, too ( sequel ) about the live... S also introduced before he ’ s death becomes less about guilt over alchemy-driven and! Him not to back out now, and then watch Brotherhood a few a hours ago i finished movie! About a civil war that resulted in a genocide due to State alchemists questions if ’. Lot better before they try to bring their mom back, and he dies gets. They react when equivalent exchange ever produced and they are both worth the watch the. Granted a chance to apply meaningful in the world the ending of Brotherhood the silliest moments... The biggest difference in my opinion through this part ( they seem to assume watched. Al, over and over, expresses concern at what they ’ re doing familiar they..., people don ’ t need to watch both, then definitely go with FMA,... 'M really enjoying it are literally in it together so quickly complex homunculus was Greed, who tied! Get used to it, therefore, indirectly being responsible for the past two weeks, a... That means just watch Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood are two young brothers who live in a nutshell you. Writers and artists want you to laugh, they will guarantee that you snicker at the... Fma and FMAB, and they are both willing and complicit in their right... Story first than to suddenly jump on the same timeline, but very differently made both parts.